Abstract:Abstract Since the 1970s, scientists have developed statistical methods intended to formalize detection of changes in global climate and to attribute such changes to relevant causal factors, natural and anthropogenic. Detection and attribution (D&A) of climate change trends is commonly performed using a variant of Hasselmann’s “optimal fingerprinting” method, which involves a linear regression of historical climate observations on corresponding output from numerical climate models. However, it has long been known in the field of time series analysis that regressions of “non-stationary” or “trending” variables are, in general, statistically inconsistent and often spurious. When non-stationarity is caused by “integrated” processes, as is likely the case for climate variables, consistency of least-squares estimators depends on “cointegration” of regressors. This study has shown, using an idealized linear-response-model framework, that if standard assumptions hold then the optimal fingerprinting estimator is consistent, and hence robust against spurious regression. In the case of global mean surface temperature (GMST), parameterizing abstract linear response models in terms of energy balance provides this result with physical interpretability. Hypothesis tests conducted using observations of historical GMST and simulation output from 13 CMIP6 general circulation models produced no evidence that standard assumptions required for consistency were violated. It is therefore concluded that, at least in the case of GMST, detection and attribution of climate change trends is very likely not spurious regression. Furthermore, detection of significant cointegration between observations and model output indicates that the least-squares estimator is “superconsistent”, with better convergence properties than might previously have been assumed. Finally, a new method has been developed for quantifying D&A uncertainty, exploiting the notion of cointegration to eliminate the need for pre-industrial control simulations.

Scaling fluctuation analysis and statistical hypothesis testing of anthropogenic warming

Uncertainties in the attribution of greenhouse gas warming and implications for climate prediction

Palaeoclimate Constraints on the Impact of 2 °C Anthropogenic Warming and Beyond

Global Warming: some back-of-the-envelope calculations

The Shifts Hypothesis - an alternative view of global climate change

Dangerous human-made interference with climate: A GISS modelE study

Probing the timescale dependency of local and global variations in surface air temperature from climate simulations and reconstructions of the last millennia

Inference Related to Common Breaks in a Multivariate System with Joined Segmented Trends with Applications to Global and Hemispheric Temperatures

Detection and Attribution of Climate Change: a Regional Perspective

Separating signal and noise in atmospheric temperature changes: The importance of timescale

Earth climate identification vs. anthropic global warming attribution

Climate Change Attribution Using Empirical Decomposition of Climatic Data

Solar and planetary oscillation control on climate change: hind-cast, forecast and a comparison with the CMIP5 GCMs

Footprint of greenhouse forcing in daily temperature variability

Detection of Regional Surface Temperature Trends

Empirical estimation of anthropogenic and natural contributions to surface air temperature trends at different latitudes

Dynamic responses of atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration to global temperature changes between 1850 and 2010

A Simple Relationship Between the Magnitude and Spatial Extent of Global Surface Temperature Anomalies

Stochastic assessment of temperature-CO2 causal relationship in climate from the Phanerozoic through modern times

Long-term natural variability and 20th century climate change

Could detection and attribution of climate change trends be spurious regression?