Abstract:The demand for better representation of cultural considerations in environmental management is increasingly evident. As two cases in point, ecosystem service approaches increasingly include cultural services, and resource planners recognize indigenous constituents and the cultural knowledge they hold as key to good environmental management. Accordingly, collaborations between anthropologists, planners, decision makers and biodiversity experts about the subject of culture are increasingly common-but also commonly fraught. Those whose expertise is culture often engage in such collaborations because they worry a practitioner from 'elsewhere' will employ a 'measure of culture' that is poorly or naively conceived. Those from an economic or biophysical training must grapple with the intangible properties of culture as they intersect with economic, biological or other material measures. This paper seeks to assist those who engage in collaborations to characterize cultural benefits or impacts relevant to decision-making in three ways; by: (i) considering the likely mindset of would-be collaborators; (ii) providing examples of tested approaches that might enable innovation; and (iii) characterizing the kinds of obstacles that are in principle solvable through methodological alternatives. We accomplish these tasks in part by examining three cases wherein culture was a critical variable in environmental decision making: risk management in New Zealand associated with Māori concerns about genetically modified organisms; cultural services to assist marine planning in coastal British Columbia; and a decision-making process involving a local First Nation about water flows in a regulated river in western Canada. We examine how 'culture' came to be manifest in each case, drawing from ethnographic and cultural-models interviews and using subjective metrics (recommended by theories of judgment and decision making) to express cultural concerns. We conclude that the characterization of cultural benefits and impacts is least amenable to methodological solution when prevailing cultural worldviews contain elements fundamentally at odds with efforts to quantify benefits/impacts, but that even in such cases some improvements are achievable if decision-makers are flexible regarding processes for consultation with community members and how quantification is structured.

Cost–Benefit Analysis: A Decision-Support Tool or a Venue for Contesting Ecosystem Knowledge?

COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS IN COASTAL MANAGEMENT – USEFUL OR FLAWED?

‘What You See is All There is’: The Importance of Heuristics in Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Social Return on Investment (SROI) in the Evaluation of Public Health Interventions

Cost–benefit analysis and 'next best' methods to evaluate the efficiency of social policies: As in pitching horseshoes, closeness matters

Economics and the Endangered Species Act

A Bayesian approach to ecosystem service trade-off analysis utilizing expert knowledge

Exploring trade-offs in agro-ecological landscapes: using a multi-objective land-use allocation model to support agroforestry research

Rules for the rulemakers: asymmetric information and the political economy of benefit-cost analysis

Aligning Agent-Based Modeling With Multi-Objective Land-Use Allocation: Identification of Policy Gaps and Feasible Pathways to Biophysically Optimal Landscapes

Culture, intangibles and metrics in environmental management

On the environmental effectiveness of the EU Marine Strategy Framework Directive

Uncertainty, climate change, and irreversible environmental effects: application of real options to environmental benefit-cost analysis

Cost-benefit analysis of ecosystem modeling to support fisheries management

Cost-benefit analysis of ecosystem modelling to support fisheries management

Opportunities for improved consideration of cultural benefits in environmental decision-Making

The once and future application of cost-effectiveness analysis

Accounting for economy-wide effects, risk aversion, and inequality aversion in the cost-benefit analyses of extreme events

The standing of foreign lenders in cost-benefit analysis: some implications for environmental appraisals

Bounded Rationality: Cognitive Limitations or Adaptation to the Environment? The Implications of Ecological Rationality for Management Learning

Collaboration and engagement with decision-makers are needed to reduce evidence complacency in wildlife management

Assessing Costs and Benefits of Measures to Achieve Good Environmental Status in European Regional Seas: Challenges, Opportunities, and Lessons Learnt