Abstract:Research on land use policy has been vexed by the pivotal question of which institutions achieve credibility. Scholars have been split as it has been difficult to assess credibility. To provide a solution, an alternative theory pushed forward a renewed understanding of the question why some property rights succeed while others fail. At its heart is the axiom that Form – be it private/public, secure/insecure or formal/informal – follows from Function. This position – aka the Credibility Thesis – has propelled a fundamental change on the study of land, housing, settlements and resources evidenced through a steady stream of publications. Building on this literature, this collection reports several findings: 1) theoretical – credibility revolves around maintaining congruence between the function of institutions; 2) methodological – credibility can be measured via conflict, perceptual divergences and shifts over time; 3) empirical – institutions tend to change when functional congruence is disregarded while enduring when it is safeguarded. The findings cover different geographies (ranging from India and Ethiopia to China and Colombia) demonstrating the theory’s applicability. The collection ends with a double treatise; one pointing out like-minded bodies of thought with reference to Elinor Ostrom and another identifying quandaries that research must consider. To appreciate the collection’s main thrust, this introduction leads it off by reviewing 10 years’ research on the Credibility Thesis in terms of the field, findings and future.

Legitimacy, Institutional Design, and Dispute Settlement: The Case of Eco-Certification Systems

The Contribution of Environmental and Social Standards Towards Ensuring Legitimacy in Supply Chain Governance

Closing the Legitimacy Gap in Global Environmental Governance? Lessons from the Emerging CDM Market

Exploring the Output Legitimacy of Transnational Fisheries Governance

The legitimacy crisis of investor-state arbitration and the new EU investment court system

On the Role of Institutional Logics in Legitimacy Evaluations: The Effects of Pricing and CSR Signals on Organizational Legitimacy

Organizational Legitimacy

Navigating Input and Output Legitimacy in Multi-Stakeholder Initiatives: Institutional Stewards at Work

Assessing the Normative Legitimacy of Investment Arbitration: The EU’s Investment Court System

Dealing with Institutional Distances in International Marketing Channels: Governance Strategies that Engender Legitimacy and Efficiency

Controversy Over Voluntary Environmental Standards: A Socioeconomic Analysis of the Marine Stewardship Council

The Public Legitimacy of Multistakeholder Partnerships in Global Environmental Governance: Evidence from Survey Experiments in Brazil, the United Kingdom, and the United States

How Shall We Judge Agri-Food Governance? Legitimacy Constructions in Food Democracy and Co-Regulation Discourses

Vertically Differentiating Environmental Standards: The Case of the Marine Stewardship Council

Resolving Investor State Dispute Settlement’s Legitimacy Crisis: The Case for Reinstating the Requirement to Exhaust Local Remedies

On the Empirical Measurement of Legitimacy

Legitimacy Deficits of International Organizations: design, drift, and decoupling at the UN Security Council

The Credibility Thesis, a Decade Onwards: A Review of the Theoretical Field, Findings and Future

Certifying New Technologies

Certification Design With Common Values

Institutional Legitimacy: An Exegesis Of Normative Incentives