Abstract:Problem definition: Misconduct, such as theft, is a major problem in operational settings, and staffing decisions can either amplify or mitigate this problem as workers influence their peers’ behavior. Peers are known to influence coworker productivity and likely also affect counterproductive behaviors. Academic/practical relevance: Many studies have shown how mechanisms such as helping, knowledge transfer, teaching, and social pressure generate productivity peer effects in service and other settings. Yet few papers empirically examine these effects in counterproductive behaviors. We argue that while the same mechanisms driving productivity spillovers also generate peer effects in misconduct, an additional effect—strategic peer response—reflects how coworkers, under managerial monitoring, adjust misconduct in response to peers’ daily behavior. An additional contribution of this paper is to identify the effect of peers on operational performance in a firm setting. Methodology: We use transaction and theft data from 83,153 servers at 1,049 restaurants across 46 states in the United States. We employ instrumental variable (IV) models to account for both reflection problems and correlated error terms in same-day peer theft. We use Monte Carlo simulations to present how biases identified by a combination of ordinary least squares (OLS) and IV models suggest that managerial oversight might generate negative correlation in the same-day error terms of peers that reflects strategic peer responses. Results: Our results show that although servers are more likely to steal when working with high-theft peers, they steal less as peers steal more on a given day. We also show that this negative correlation in daily peer theft is higher under an information technology system that increases managerial oversight by reporting likely theft to managers. Importantly, we demonstrate how reflection effects can significantly amplify even small peer-effect coefficients to have large organizational implications. Our parameter estimates indicate that doubling a single worker’s average theft amount will increase total theft in an average restaurant by 76%. Doubling all workers’ theft amounts increases totals by 550%. Finally, we show that the positive peer effect from high-theft coworkers only exists for new workers in their first three to five months on the job, consistent with imprinting mechanisms that include knowledge transfer and norms. Managerial implications: The results show that the costs of employing unethical workers is higher than the direct cost of those workers’ misconduct because their behavior spills over into coworkers’ actions and amplifies through reflection effects. Yet our results also suggest that this contagion can be mitigated by managerial oversight. So long as there is sufficient monitoring of misconduct, workers will strategically limit such behavior in response to peers.

When Does the Devil Make Work? An Empirical Study of the Impact of Workload on Worker Productivity

Workload Characterization of E-Commerce Site by Modeling Customer Behavior

Duality of Workload in Teams: A Daily Investigation of Team Workload and Team Functioning

The Timing of Staffing Decisions in Hospital Operating Rooms: Incorporating Workload Heterogeneity into the Newsvendor Problem

Characterizing the Impact of the Workload on the Value of Dynamic Resizing in Data Centers

Optimal Staffing for Online-to-Offline On-Demand Delivery Systems: In-House or Crowd-Sourcing Drivers?

Unwarranted Overtime: Exploring the Origins and Mitigation Strategies for Excessive Work Hours Among Employees

The Influence of Peers in Worker Misconduct: Evidence from Restaurant Theft

Production Automation Upgrades and the Mystery of Workers' Overwork: Evidence from a Manufacturing Employer-employee Matching Survey in China

Does Workforce Reduction Actually Work? A Multilevel Research on Contextual Factors

Manufacturing Productivity with Worker Turnover

The effects of big data analytics and workplace pressures on productivity

Management and Shocks to Worker Productivity

How Organizational Inefficiency Adversely Affects Number-of-Employee Based Production Outputs

Recover Overnight? Work Interruption and Worker Productivity

Do Customer Emotions Affect Agent Speed? An Empirical Study of Emotional Load in Online Customer Contact Centers

Understanding Work Rhythms in Software Development and Their Effects on Technical Performance

The Impacts of Algorithmic Work Assignment on Fairness Perceptions and Productivity: Evidence from Field Experiments

The Efficiency of Slacking off: Evidence From the Emergency Department

Measurements of team workload: A time pressure and scenario complexity study for maritime operation tasks

Declining Responsiveness at the Establishment Level: Sources and Productivity Implications