Abstract:In a previous study, students' self-expressed learning orientations towards an exercise centered on self-monitoring one's ability to solve a pre-lab physics problem were identified from a post-test feedback survey given to an introductory algebra-based physics student population spanning six measured semesters, and examined as a potential variable in course performance, force and motion conceptual understanding, and attitudes towards learning physics. The sampled population, which primarily consists of life science majors, was also asked in the same feedback survey to discuss what portion or portions of the course were relevant to their respective choices of major. In this study, we examine the fact that about 50 students out of 218 sampled students, or 23% of the sample population, explicitly stated that they perceived no relevance at all of the course to their respective majors, whereas the other 168 students cited portions of the course or the entirety of the course as being relevant to their majors. A follow-up investigation of perceived relevance versus irrelevance shows that attitudes towards physics will experience more expert-like shifts for students who perceive relevance than students who do not; in particular, the attitudinal survey's item clusters that pertain to personal interest and real-world connections appear to show the strongest effect. Further examination showed that biology majors and health science majors (two distinctive sub-populations of life science majors) show similar pre-post trends for relevance vs. irrelevance perceptions, whereas students with a performance achievement goal appeared to bifurcate between a novice-like shift for perceived irrelevance and no attitudinal shift from pre to post for perceived relevance. Discussion includes emphasis on limitations imposed by institution type among other factors.

Undergraduate Psychology’s Scientific Identity Dilemma

Psychology is a Science: At Least Some Students Think So

Professionals’ Identification Within and Across Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Fields

Analyzing Physics Majors' Specialization Low Interest Using Social Cognitive Career Theory

Predictors of Student Satisfaction with University Psychology Courses: A Review

Gender, Empathy, and the Choice of the Psychology Major

Learning goals and perceived irrelevance to major within life science majors in introductory physics

Can Teaching Data Analysis In-House Improve Psychology Students’ Skills?

Psychology’s Status as a Science: Peculiarities and Intrinsic Challenges. Moving Beyond its Current Deadlock Towards Conceptual Integration

Career Change Intentions of Science and Engineering Undergraduates: A Behavioral Neuroscience Inquiry

Profiles of John Henryism and subjective task value in higher education: the motivations and attributions of nontraditional students

The effects of vocational interest on study results: Student person – environment fit and program interest diversity

Scientific Research Identity Development Need Not Wait Until College: Examining the Motivational Impact of a Pre-college Authentic Research Experience

Addressing the divergence between health science students’ learning preferences and the way their teachers teach

Undergraduate choice of major and major satisfaction: an expanded role for personality measures

Interpersonal Rejection Sensitivity and Regulatory Focus Theory to Explain College Students' Class Engagement

Examining How Student Identities Interact with an Immersive Field Ecology Course and its Implications for Graduate School Education

Students’ Personality Types, Intended Majors, and College Expectations: Further Evidence Concerning Psychological and Sociological Interpretations of Holland’s Theory

Potential relationship of chosen major to problem solving attitudes and course performance

Exploring Subfield Interest Development in Undergraduate Physics Students through Social Cognitive Career Theory

Psychology Students’ Expectations Regarding Educational Requirements and Salary for Desired Careers