Abstract:Background: Next-generation sequencing (NGS) approaches have revolutionized gut microbiome research and can provide strain-level resolution, but these techniques have limitations in that they are only semi-quantitative, suffer from high detection limits, and generate data that is compositional. The present study aimed to systematically compare quantitative PCR (qPCR) and droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) for the absolute quantification of Limosilactobacillus reuteri strains in human fecal samples and to develop an optimized protocol for the absolute quantification of bacterial strains in fecal samples. Results: Using strain-specific PCR primers for L. reuteri 17938, ddPCR showed slightly better reproducibility, but qPCR was almost as reproducible and showed comparable sensitivity (limit of detection [LOD] around 104 cells/g feces) and linearity (R2 > 0.98) when kit-based DNA isolation methods were used. qPCR further had a wider dynamic range and is cheaper and faster. Based on these findings, we conclude that qPCR has advantages over ddPCR for the absolute quantification of bacterial strains in fecal samples. We provide an optimized and easy-to-follow step-by-step protocol for the design of strain-specific qPCR assays, starting from primer design from genome sequences to the calibration of the PCR system. Validation of this protocol to design PCR assays for two L. reuteri strains, PB-W1 and DSM 20016 T, resulted in a highly accurate qPCR with a detection limit in spiked fecal samples of around 103 cells/g feces. Applying our strain-specific qPCR assays to fecal samples collected from human subjects who received live L. reuteri PB-W1 or DSM 20016 T during a human trial demonstrated a highly accurate quantification and sensitive detection of these two strains, with a much lower LOD and a broader dynamic range compared to NGS approaches (16S rRNA gene sequencing and whole metagenome sequencing). Conclusions: Based on our analyses, we consider qPCR with kit-based DNA extraction approaches the best approach to accurately quantify gut bacteria at the strain level in fecal samples. The provided step-by-step protocol will allow scientists to design highly sensitive strain-specific PCR systems for the accurate quantification of bacterial strains of not only L. reuteri but also other bacterial taxa in a broad range of applications and sample types. Video Abstract.

Comparison of droplet digital PCR and quantitative real-time PCR for examining population dynamics of bacteria in soil

ddPCR surpasses classical qPCR technology in quantitating bacteria and fungi in the environment

Recent Advance in Digital PCR

Highly accurate and sensitive absolute quantification of bacterial strains in human fecal samples

Droplet digital PCR as an emerging tool in detecting pathogens nucleic acids in infectious diseases

Comparison of microbial molecular diagnosis efficiency within unstable template metagenomic DNA samples between qRT-PCR and chip-based digital PCR platforms

Assessment of Common Factors Associated with Droplet Digital PCR (ddPCR) Quantification of Paratrichodorus allius in Soil

Quantitative or digital PCR? A comparative analysis for choosing the optimal one for biosensing applications

Detection and quantification of <i>Verticillium dahliae</i> and <i>V. longisporum</i> by droplet digital PCR versus quantitative real-time PCR

Comparison of two digital PCR methods for EGFR DNA and SARS-CoV-2 RNA quantification

Analytical comparisons of SARS-COV-2 detection by qRT-PCR and ddPCR with multiple primer/probe sets

Comparison of an automated DNA extraction and 16S rDNA real time PCR/sequencing diagnostic method using optimized reagents with culture during a 15-month study using specimens from sterile body sites

Qualitative and quantitative detection of surgical pathogenic microorganisms Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus based on ddPCR system

Droplet digital PCR technology promises new applications and research areas

Droplet-based Digital PCR (ddpcr) and Its Applications

Digital PCR-An Emerging Technology with Broad Applications in Microbiology.

Establishment of Quantifying and Typing Analysis of 16S Rrna Gene by Real-Time PCR

Comparison of multi-parallel quantitative real-time PCRs targeting different DNA regions and detecting soil-transmitted helminths in stool

Optimization of digital droplet polymerase chain reaction for quantification of genetically modified organisms

Droplet digital PCR method for the absolute quantitative detection and monitoring of Lacticaseibacillus casei

Development and Evaluation of a Single Dye Duplex Droplet Digital PCR Assay for the Rapid Detection and Quantification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis