Abstract:Our understanding of animal mating systems has changed dramatically with the advent of molecular methods to determine individuals’ reproductive success. But why are older behavioral descriptions and newer genetic descriptions of mating systems often seemingly inconsistent? We argue that a potentially important reason for such inconsistencies is a research trajectory rooted in early studies that were equivocal and overreaching, followed by studies that accepted earlier conclusions at face value and assumed, rather than tested, key ideas about animal mating systems. We illustrate our argument using Anolis lizards, whose social behavior has been studied for nearly a century. A dominant view emerging from this behavioral research was that anoles display strict territorial polygyny, where females mate with just the one male in whose territory they reside. However, all genetic evidence suggests that females frequently mate with multiple males. We trace this mismatch to early studies that concluded that anoles are territorial based on limited data. Subsequent research assumed territoriality implicitly or explicitly, resulting in studies that were unlikely to uncover or consider important any evidence of anoles’ departures from strict territorial polygyny. Thus, descriptions of anole behavior were largely led away from predicting a pattern of female multiple mating. We end by considering the broader implications of such erratic trajectories for the study of animal mating systems and posit that precise definitions, renewed attention to natural history, and explicitly questioning assumptions made while collecting behavioral observations will allow us to move towards a fuller understanding of animal mating systems.Significance statementMismatches between behavioral and genetic descriptions of mating systems are widespread across animals. We argue that these discrepancies can arise from the erratic and contingent progression of research on space use behavior and social interactions. We demonstrate such a trajectory in Anolis lizards, where decades of behavioral data led not only to the conclusion that anoles are territorial but also to the erroneous expectation, disproven by genetic evidence, that each female mates with just one male. The earliest studies concluded that anoles are territorial based on flimsy evidence, leading subsequent studies to implicitly and explicitly assume territorial behavior; later studies were thus unlikely to detect, or consider important, departures from territoriality that could facilitate female multiple mating. Such research trajectories are likely not unique to anoles, and we contend that avoiding these trajectories requires renewed and continued attention to the natural history of even well-studied organisms.

The erratic and contingent progression of research on territoriality: a case study

Alternative Mating Tactics in Socially Monogamous Prairie Voles, Microtus ochrogaster

Causes and consequences of inverse density-dependent territorial behaviour and aggression in a monogamous mammal

Polyandry and Polygyny in a Social Rodent: An Integrative Perspective Based on Social Organization, Copulations, and Genetics

Social mating systems in birds: Resource-defense polygamy-but not lekking-is a macroevolutionarily unstable trait

Character displacement in the midst of background evolution in island populations of Anolis lizards: A spatiotemporal perspective

Multiple routes to interspecific territoriality in sister species of North American perching birds

Costs of territoriality: a review of hypotheses, meta-analysis, and field study

Beyond color and pattern: elucidating the factors associated with intraspecific aggression in the mimic poison frog (Ranitomeya imitator)

Sex-biased dispersal: a review of the theory

Parity-specific differences in spatial genetics and dispersal in the common lizard

The evolutionary dynamics of plant mating systems: how bias for studying ′interesting′ plant reproductive systems could backfire

Novel and classical methods similarly describe variation in territory size among males in Neotropical poison frogs with contrasting reproductive and behavioral strategies

Meta-Analysis Reveals Behavioral Plasticity, Not Agonistic Behavior, Facilitates Invasion of Brown Anoles (Anolis sagrei) and Replacement of Green Anoles (Anolis carolinensis)

Cooperation and Coordination in Socially Monogamous Birds: Moving Away From a Focus on Sexual Conflict

STUDY PARADIGMS OF MATING SYSTEMS IN VOLES

Species identity cues in animal communication

The evolution of reversed sex roles and classical polyandry: Insights from coucals and other animals

What Causes Differences in the Age-Class Structure between Suburban and Forest Populations of Anolis homolechis?

Variation in grouping patterns, mating systems and social structure: what socio-ecological models attempt to explain

Competition and hybridization drive interspecific territoriality in birds