Editorial: Relevance Theory and Intercultural Communication Problems

Agnieszka Piskorska
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/rela-2017-0005
2017-03-30
Research in Language
Abstract:This editorial to the special issue of RiL dedicated to relevance theory and problems of intercultural communication addresses the general requirements that a theory of communication must meet to be applicable to the analysis of intercultural communication. Then it discusses criticism levelled against Grice’s theory of conversational implicature and Brown and Levinson’s theory of politeness on the grounds that these theories were not universal enough to be applied to all data. Finally, it offers some remarks on the applicability of relevance theory to intercultural pragmatics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the applicability and challenges of Relevance Theory (RT) in cross - cultural communication. Specifically, the author first reviews the criticisms encountered by Grice's Cooperative Principle and Brown and Levinson's Politeness Theory in cross - cultural studies. These criticisms mainly focus on the question of whether these theories are universal. For example, Ochs Keenan's research shows that the communication style of Malagasy people does not fully conform to Grice's Quantity Maxim, and Ide and Matsumoto point out that Brown and Levinson's Politeness Theory has limitations when analyzing politeness phenomena in Asian cultures. On this basis, the author discusses how Relevance Theory can explain problems in cross - cultural communication through its cognitive basis. Relevance Theory holds that human cognition tends to maximize relevance, and this principle is universal. Therefore, Relevance Theory can provide a more general framework when dealing with communicative behaviors in different cultural backgrounds. The author further points out that although cultural backgrounds will affect an individual's judgment of relevance, this does not mean that Relevance Theory itself is not applicable to cross - cultural situations. On the contrary, Relevance Theory can combine specific cultural rules and communicative conventions to explain the diversity and differences in cross - cultural communication. In conclusion, this paper aims to evaluate the effectiveness and limitations of Relevance Theory in cross - cultural communication research and explore its advantages as a communication model based on cognitive psychology.