Abstract:How gene regulatory networks (GRNs) encode gene expression dynamics and how GRNs evolve are not well understood, although these problems have been studied extensively. We created a digital twin that accurately reproduces expression dynamics of 13 genes that initiate expression in 32-cell ascidian embryos. We first showed that gene expression patterns can be manipulated according to predictions by this digital model. Next, to simulate GRN rewiring, we changed regulatory functions that represented their regulatory mechanisms in the digital twin, and found that in 55 of 100 cases, removal of a single regulator from a conjunctive clause of Boolean functions did not theoretically alter qualitative expression patterns of these genes. In other words, we found that more than half the regulators gave theoretically redundant temporal or spatial information to target genes. We experimentally substantiated that the expression pattern of Nodal was maintained without one of these factors, Zfpm, by changing the upstream regulatory sequence of Nodal . Such robust buffers of regulatory mechanisms may provide a basis of enabling developmental system drift, or rewiring of GRNs without changing expression patterns of downstream genes, during evolution. Although regulatory relationships in gene regulatory networks have been studied extensively during the past two decades, it is not fully understood how gene regulatory networks produce gene expression dynamics. One major reason is the difficulty of experimentally determining "regulatory functions" that mathematically describe how individual genes are regulated. Because of simplicity of embryonic structure and compactness of the genome, ascidian embryos provide an ideal system for analyzing dynamics of gene regulatory networks. In 32-cell ascidian embryos, there are only 13 regulatory genes that initiate expression. Regulatory functions for these genes, which are represented as Boolean functions, collectively constitute a digital twin that reproduces gene expression dynamics at single-cell resolution throughout the whole embryo. The digital twin is a powerful tool for exploring mechanisms that are not readily accessible in experiments using real embryos. We found that over half the regulators in regulatory functions are potentially redundant for specifying temporal and spatial gene expression patterns. It is generally believed that regulatory functions have changed frequently during evolution, and our results show that a gene regulatory network in early ascidian embryos has robust buffers, which constitute a basis for developmental system drift.

Assessing regulatory information in developmental gene regulatory networks

Regulatory gene networks and the properties of the developmental process

Developmental Effector Gene Regulation: Multiplexed Strategies for Functional Analysis

Regulatory Network Characterization in Development: Challenges and Opportunities.

A digital twin reproducing gene regulatory network dynamics of early Ciona embryos indicates robust buffers in the network

Functional Cis -Regulatory Genomics for Systems Biology

Behavior-related gene regulatory networks: A new level of organization in the brain

Gene regulatory network of renal primordium development

Gene regulatory network structure informs the distribution of perturbation effects

Networking Development by Boolean Logic

Decoding the Regulatory Network of Early Blood Development from Single-Cell Gene Expression Measurements.

Modularity, criticality, and evolvability of a developmental gene regulatory network

A meta-analysis of Boolean network models reveals design principles of gene regulatory networks

Networking development by Boolean logic.

Emerging properties of animal gene regulatory networks

Feedbacks from the metabolic network to the genetic network reveal regulatory modules in E. coli and B. subtilis

Developmental rewiring of the NGAL/CUC/KLU network associated with pleiotropic roles of NGAL genes

Automatic design of gene regulatory mechanisms for spatial pattern formation

Stepwise Bayesian Machine Learning Uncovers a Novel Gene Regulatory Network Component in Neural Tube Development

Developmental gene regulatory network connections predicted by machine learning from gene expression data alone