Abstract:The urgency of climate change calls for rapid mitigation and bioenergy is projected to play a major role in temperate regions. To comprehensively examine the environmental sustainability implications of expanding agricultural bioenergy production, we synthesized the existing scientific literature on biodiversity and ecosystem service impacts from land‐use changes to feedstock production in temperate agricultural landscapes. Synergistic benefits for biodiversity and ecosystem services mainly occur when perennial feedstock is integrated into intensive arable landscapes. The use of marginal and abandoned land could alleviate trade‐offs with food production, but our review shows that ecological impacts are largely unknown and needs further research. The Paris agreement on climate change requires rapid reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. One important mitigation strategy, at least in the intermediate future, is the substitution of fossil fuels with bioenergy. However, using agriculture‐ and forest‐derived biomass for energy has sparked controversy regarding both the climate mitigation potential and conflicts with biodiversity conservation. The urgency of the climate crisis calls for using forests for carbon sequestration and storage rather than for bioenergy, making agricultural biomass an attractive alternative for fossil energy substitution. However, this calls for comprehensive assessments of its sustainability in terms of consequences for biodiversity and ecosystem services. In this review, we provide a first holistic overview of the impacts on ecosystems of land‐use changes from bioenergy crop production in temperate climates, by synthesizing results on both biodiversity and ecosystem service impacts. We found that bioenergy‐related land‐use changes can have both positive and negative effects on ecosystems, with original land use, bioenergy crop type and scale of bioenergy production being important moderators of impacts. Despite the risk of opportunity cost for food production, perennial crop cultivation on arable land had the lowest occurrence of negative impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem services. Growing biomass for bioenergy on surplus land has been suggested as a way to alleviate competition with food production and biodiversity conservation, but our results demonstrate that utilizing marginal or abandoned land for bioenergy crop production cannot fully resolve these trade‐offs. Furthermore, there is a lack of empirical studies of the biodiversity value of marginal and abandoned land, limiting our understanding of the sustainability implications of biomass cultivation on surplus land. We argue that future research and policies for bioenergy production must explicitly consider biodiversity and ecosystem services in combination to avoid potential trade‐offs between the two and to ensure sustainable bioenergy production.

Energy from Biomass for Sustainable Cities

From Organic Wastes to Bioenergy, Biofuels, and Value-Added Products for Urban Sustainability and Circular Economy: A Review

Woodchips from Forest Residues as a Sustainable and Circular Biofuel for Electricity Production: Evidence from an Environmental Life Cycle Assessment

Garden waste biomass for renewable and sustainable energy production in China: Potential, challenges and development

Sustainable biofuel: A question of scale and aims

The potential of wood-based urban waste to generate bioenergy and increase the energetic sustainability

Biomass to Energy — an Analysis of Current Technologies, Prospects, and Challenges

Utilization and development of biomass energy

Eco-efficiency in the transformation of forest biomass residues in electrical energy

Sustainability assessment of the whole biomass-to-energy chain of a combined heat and power plant based on biomass gasification: biomass supply chain management and life cycle assessment

Stand der Technik und Trends bei der Erzeugung von Strom und Treibstoffen aus Holz

Heat, electricity, or transportation? The optimal use of residual and waste biomass in Europe from an environmental perspective

Assessment of agricultural biomass residues to replace fossil fuel and hydroelectric power energy: A spatial approach

Assessing the Sustainability of Agricultural Bioenergy Potential in the European Union

Biomass Polygeneration Systems Integrated with Buildings: A Review

Bioenergy crops, biodiversity and ecosystem services in temperate agricultural landscapes—A review of synergies and trade‐offs

Bioenergy to save the world. Producing novel energy plants for growth on abandoned land

Potential Usage, Vertical Value Chain and Challenge of Biomass Resource: Evidence from China'S Crop Residues

Utilization of Biomass to Ash: An Overview of the Potential Resources for Alternative Energy

The Role of Biowaste: A Multi-Objective Optimization Platform for Combined Heat, Power and Fuel

Embracing the sustainable horizons through bioenergy innovations: a path to a sustainable energy future