Abstract:Despite strong specialization to gypsum soils, past divergent selection related to climatic gradients has driven adaptive population differentiation in Lepidium subulatum. All populations showed high but similar plasticity to drought, indicating that selection did not act against plasticity in harsh environmental conditions. Populations from mesic sites may be particularly vulnerable to climate change, given their lower fitness under both wet and dry conditions. Phenotypic differences among populations stem from the interaction between neutral and adaptive processes, and phenotypic plasticity. Although clinal trait variation along climatic gradients often evolves in widely distributed species, it is unknown whether substrate specialization, such as that of Mediterranean gypsum plants, has constrained adaptation to climate. Using a common garden experiment with two contrasting watering treatments, we quantified phenotypic plasticity, assessed evidence for footprints of selection using FST – QST comparisons, and evaluated the ecological factors driving genetically based phenotypic differentiation of 11 populations encompassing the full environmental range of the gypsum shrub Lepidium subulatum. We found evidence for genetic differentiation among populations related to climatic differences, with populations from warmer and drier sites showing lower specific leaf area and leaf N, earlier phenology, greater water use efficiency and greater fitness. Multiple lines of evidence suggest that this differentiation was driven by past divergent selection rather than neutral processes. All populations showed high phenotypic plasticity, indicating that plasticity has not been selected against, even in populations from sites with harsher climatic conditions. Synthesis. Our results indicate that despite strong substrate specialization, adaptive differentiation related to climatic gradients occurs in this species. However, we also found that populations from mesic sites may be particularly vulnerable to future climate change given their relatively lower fitness under both wet and dry conditions. Resumen Las diferencias fenotípicas entre poblaciones son fruto de la interacción entre los procesos evolutivos neutrales y adaptativos, y la plasticidad fenotípica. Las poblaciones de especies ampliamente distribuidas a menudo muestran diferencias fenotípicas asociadas a un determinado gradiente ambiental. Sin embargo, se desconoce si la especialización a substratos específicos, como la ocurrida en las plantas mediterráneas restringidas a suelos de yeso, ha podido limitar su adaptación al clima. Usando un experimento de jardín común con dos tratamientos contrastados de disponibilidad hídrica, hemos evaluado los patrones de plasticidad fenotípica, la evidencia de huellas de selección pasada mediante comparaciones FST ‐ QST, y los factores ecológicos involucrados en la diferenciación fenotípica de base genética de 11 poblaciones a lo largo de todo el gradiente ambiental del arbusto gipsófito Lepidium subulatum. Encontramos diferenciación genética ligada a diferencias climáticas. Las poblaciones de sitios más cálidos y secos mostraron menor área foliar específica y nitrógeno foliar, fenologías adelantadas, mayor eficiencia del uso del agua y mayor éxito reproductivo. Múltiples evidencias sugieren que dicha diferenciación ha sido causada por selección divergente pasada en vez de por procesos neutrales. Todas las poblaciones mostraron una elevada plasticidad fenotípica, lo que indica que la selección natural no ha actuado en contra de la plasticidad, incluso en las poblaciones con condiciones ambientales más duras. Síntesis. Nuestros resultados muestran que, a pesar de la fuerte especialización al sustrato, existe diferenciación fenotípica adaptativa asociada a un gradiente climático en esta especie. No obstante, las poblaciones de sitios más fríos y húmedos podrían mostrar una mayor vulnerabilidad al cambio climático, debido a su menor éxito reproductivo tanto en condiciones de sequía como de alta disponibilidad hídrica.

Water use segregation among plants with contrasting root depth and distribution along gypsum hills

Isotopes reveal contrasting water use strategies among coexisting plant species in a Mediterranean ecosystem

Contrasting plant water‐use responses to groundwater depth in coastal dune ecosystems

The combined effects of a long‐term experimental drought and an extreme drought on the use of plant‐water sources in a Mediterranean forest

Dynamic hydrological niche segregation: how plants compete for water in a semiarid ecosystem

Water utilization characteristics of dominant plant species from different functional groups of desert steppe

Water use characteristics of coexisting sand‐binding vegetation in two typical soil habitats in the desert steppe of China

Lithologically controlled subsurface critical zone thickness and water storage capacity determine regional plant community composition

Nutritional convergence in plants growing on gypsum soils in two distinct climatic regions

Range‐wide intraspecific variation reflects past adaptation to climate in a gypsophile Mediterranean shrub

Together but different: co-occurring dune plant species differ in their water- and nitrogen-use strategies

Spatio‐temporal heterogeneity in soil water stable isotopic composition and its ecohydrologic implications in semiarid ecosystems

Insight into Canary Island pine physiology provided by stable isotope patterns of water and plant tissues along an altitudinal gradient

Root depth and morphology in response to soil drought: comparing ecological groups along the secondary succession in a tropical dry forest

Isohydricity and hydraulic isolation explain reduced hydraulic failure risk in an experimental tree species mixture

Water status dynamics and drought tolerance of juvenile European beech, Douglas fir and Norway spruce trees as dependent on neighborhood and nitrogen supply.

Linking water sources with foliar nutrient status in upland plant communities in the Everglades National Park, USA

Water stable isotope characteristics and water use strategies of co-occurring plants in ecological and economic forests in subtropical monsoon regions

Vulnerability to cavitation, hydraulic efficiency, growth and survival in an insular pine (Pinus canariensis)

Nutritional strategy underlying plant specialization to gypsum soils

Watering the trees for the forest: Drought alleviation in oaks and pines by ancestral ditches