Mike Aguilar,Walter I. Boudry,Robert A. Connolly
Abstract:We study the dynamics of pricing efficiency in the equity REIT market from 1993 to 2014. We measure pricing efficiency at the firm level using variance ratios calculated from quote midpoints in the TAQ database. We find four main results. First, on average, the market is efficient, with variance ratios close to one. However, in any given year, there is considerable cross‐sectional variation in variance ratios, suggesting at least some firms are priced inefficiently. Second, higher institutional ownership by active institutional investors is related to better pricing efficiency, while passive ownership does not reduce pricing efficiency. Third, REITs that are included in the S&P 500 and S&P 400 are priced more efficiently than other REITs. For the S&P 500 firms, we find evidence that this was purely driven by sample selection, while for S&P 400 firms, we find evidence that it is inclusion in the index that drives efficiency. Finally, we find evidence that firm investment, analyst coverage and debt capital raising activity can influence pricing efficiency.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?
This paper aims to study the dynamic of pricing efficiency in the Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) market from 1993 to 2014. Specifically, the author attempts to answer the following key questions:
1. **How is the overall pricing efficiency of the market?**
- Research shows that, on the whole, the REIT market is efficient, that is, the variance ratio is close to 1. However, within any specific year, there are significant differences in the variance ratios of different companies, indicating that at least some companies may have inefficient pricing situations.
2. **What factors have influenced the pricing efficiency of the REIT market?**
- The author explores the influence of multiple factors on pricing efficiency through analysis, mainly including:
- **Institutional investors' ownership**: Higher ownership by active institutional investors is associated with better pricing efficiency, while the ownership of passive institutional investors does not affect pricing efficiency.
- **Inclusion in the S&P index**: REITs included in the S&P 500 and S&P 400 indices are more efficiently priced. For S&P 500 companies, this efficiency is mainly driven by sample selection; for S&P 400 companies, it is because inclusion in the index itself improves efficiency.
- **Corporate investment activities, analyst coverage, and debt capital - raising activities**: These factors are also found to be able to affect pricing efficiency. For example, more analyst coverage is associated with higher pricing efficiency.
3. **How has the pricing efficiency of the REIT market changed in the time series?**
- Research shows that the pricing efficiency of the REIT market fluctuates over time. The variance ratio distribution in some years (such as 2009) is relatively concentrated, while in other years (such as 1998), the distribution shows a long left - tail, indicating that the change in efficiency is dynamic.
### Overview of methods
To evaluate the pricing efficiency of the REIT market, the author uses the mid - quote data in the TAQ database to calculate the variance ratio. The variance ratio is an important tool for measuring market efficiency. Its basic idea is: if the market price follows a random walk model, then the variance of price changes should have a linear relationship with the holding period. The specific formula is as follows:
\[ VR(q)=\frac{\sigma^2_c(q)}{\sigma^2_a} \]
where,
- \( \sigma^2_a \) is an unbiased variance estimate of the 1 - period logarithmic price increment;
- \( \sigma^2_c(q) \) is \(\frac{1}{q}\) times the unbiased variance estimate of the overlapping q - period logarithmic price increment.
In addition, the author also analyzes various factors affecting pricing efficiency through a panel regression model and uses a fixed - effect model to control potential endogeneity problems.
### Conclusions
Through a detailed analysis of data from 1993 to 2014, the author concludes that although the REIT market is generally efficient, its efficiency varies significantly among different companies and in different time periods. The research results provide important empirical evidence for understanding the pricing mechanism of the REIT market and its influencing factors.