Evaluation of a Teaching Unit Based on a Problem-Solving Model for Seventh-Grade Students

Mohamed A. Shahat,Annika Ohle,Hans E. Fischer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40573-017-0068-1
2017-07-26
Zeitschrift für Didaktik der Naturwissenschaften
Abstract:In this study using a quasi-experimental design, a student-centered science teaching unit, which provided additional support to students for handling experimental material, was developed and evaluated on an ad-hoc sample of Egyptian lower secondary school students in a classroom setting. Particularly challenging for using student-centered (with the students as the focus of the activity) and student-oriented teaching (with the activity guided by the students’ ideas) are average class sizes of 40 students in Egypt. The goal of this teaching unit was to foster students’ content knowledge on density and buoyancy, problem-solving abilities, experimental strategy knowledge, motivation for learning science, and perceptions of the instruction quality in a course of five double lessons. To examine the effect of the intervention, the intervention group was taught in accordance with the model of problem solving with a student-centered and student-oriented approach, the control group learned the same content in traditional, transmissive teacher-centered (with the teacher as the focus of the activity) and teacher-oriented approach (with the activity guided by the teacher). The students in the intervention group performed significantly better – with small and medium effect sizes in all five dependent variables – than did the control group. Despite the small sample size (N = 147), this study provides evidence that the teaching unit can be effective and warrants further research to confirm these findings on larger random samples. This study contributes to research on instructional quality in large learning groups with no experience on scientific inquiry or problem solving and provides practical implications for developing countries.
English Else
What problem does this paper attempt to address?