Land, Abstraction, and Housing Provision
Javier Moreno Zacarés
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14036096.2023.2292584
2024-01-04
Housing Theory and Society
Abstract:As Anne Haila ( Citation 1990 ) noted, when the debates around land rent of the 1970s and 80s extinguished themselves, its participants split in two directions. Some took a "nomothetic" route out of it: they formulated general principles about the spatial dimensions of capital accumulation from the vantage point of abstract speculation. For Haila, David Harvey's work was the foremost example. In The Limits to Capital (Harvey Citation 1982 ), Harvey's in-depth examination of Marx's categories of rent culminated in his famous thesis that land has a tendency to assume the behaviour of a pure financial asset under capitalism. This assertion, which provides the conceptual basis of his famous "capital-switching" approach, was the product of a deductive exercise. The extent to which this was actually true he left for others to determine: "[h]ow far capitalist social formations have advanced down such a path is a matter for historical investigation" (Harvey Citation 1982 , 371). Others took an alternative route out of the rent debate: an "idiographic" path. This second group grew suspicious of grand, abstract theorizing and opted for bringing concrete phenomena into focus instead. Haila identified Michael Ball as the prime example. In a series of pieces in the 1980s, Ball criticized the infatuation of his then-fellow Marxists with Marx's cryptic writings on rent, accusing them of losing sight of how the "structures of building provision" actually worked (Ball Citation 1983 , Citation 1986 ). Of course, Ball's interest in rent theory, as well as in historical materialism more broadly, fizzled out around the turn of the 1990s. But his focus on analysing concrete "structures of provision" remained, continuing to use this approach on a series of detailed studies of housing and urban institutions (e.g. Ball Citation 1994 , Citation 1999 ).
environmental studies,urban studies,regional & urban planning