Effects of plyometric and isometric training on muscle and tendon stiffness in vivo

Keitaro Kubo,Tomonobu Ishigaki,Toshihiro Ikebukuro
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14814/phy2.13374
2017-08-01
Physiological Reports
Abstract:The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of plyometric and isometric training on tendon properties during ramp and ballistic contractions and muscle stiffness under passive and active conditions. Eleven subjects completed 12 weeks (3 days/week) of a unilateral training program for the plantar flexors. They performed plyometric training on one side (PLY) and isometric training on the other side (ISO). Active muscle stiffness in the medial gastrocnemius muscle was calculated according to changes in estimated muscle force and fascicle length during fast stretching after submaximal isometric contractions. Passive muscle stiffness was also calculated from estimated passive muscle force and fascicle length during slow passive stretching. Stiffness and hysteresis of tendon structures were measured using ultrasonography during ramp and ballistic contractions. Passive muscle stiffness and tendon hysteresis did not change for PLY or ISO Active muscle stiffness significantly increased for PLY, but not for ISO Tendon stiffness during ramp and ballistic contractions increased significantly for ISO, but not for PLY In addition, tendon elongation values at force production levels beyond 100 N during ballistic contractions increased for PLY These results suggest that plyometric training (but not isometric training) enhances the extensibility of tendon structures during ballistic contractions and active muscle stiffness during fast stretching, and these changes may be related to improved performances during stretch-shortening cycle exercises.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to compare the effects of plyometric training (PLY) and isometric training (ISO) on the stiffness of muscles and tendons under different contraction patterns. Specifically, the research focuses on the following points: 1. **Effects of Plyometric Training and Isometric Training on Tendon Properties**: The study aims to explore the effects of these two training methods on tendon stiffness and hysteresis characteristics during ramp contractions and ballistic contractions. 2. **Changes in Muscle Stiffness**: The study also compares the effects of the two training methods on the muscle stiffness of the gastrocnemius muscle under passive and active conditions. ### Research Background - **Plyometric Training**: It is generally considered that it can improve the performance of stretch - shortening cycle movements (such as jumping and sprinting), and previous studies have shown that it can change the mechanical properties of the muscle - tendon complex. - **Isometric Training**: Multiple previous studies have shown that it can significantly increase tendon stiffness. - **Limitations of Existing Research**: Most of the methods used in previous studies were unable to separately evaluate the mechanical properties of muscles and tendons, especially the tendon properties at high stretch rates (such as running and jumping). ### Research Methods - **Experimental Design**: 11 healthy men participated in a 12 - week unilateral training program, with each leg undergoing plyometric training and isometric training respectively. - **Measurement Indicators**: - **Muscle Thickness and Tendon Cross - sectional Area**: Measured by ultrasonic devices. - **Passive Muscle Stiffness**: Calculated through the changes in joint angle, passive torque and muscle fiber length during the slow passive stretching process. - **Active Muscle Stiffness**: Calculated through the changes in muscle force and muscle fiber length during the rapid stretching process. - **Tendon Stiffness and Hysteresis Characteristics**: During ramp contractions and ballistic contractions, the elongation of the tendon structure was recorded by ultrasonic devices, and its stiffness and hysteresis characteristics were calculated. ### Main Findings - **Passive Muscle Stiffness**: Neither plyometric training nor isometric training significantly changed the passive muscle stiffness. - **Active Muscle Stiffness**: Plyometric training significantly increased the active muscle stiffness, while isometric training had no obvious effect. - **Tendon Stiffness**: Isometric training significantly increased the tendon stiffness in ramp contractions and ballistic contractions, while plyometric training had no significant impact. - **Tendon Elongation**: In ballistic contractions, plyometric training increased the elongation of the tendon when the force generated exceeded 100 N. ### Conclusions The research results show that plyometric training mainly enhances the stiffness of muscles during rapid stretching and the extensibility of tendons during ballistic contractions, while isometric training significantly improves the stiffness of tendons in ramp and ballistic contractions. These changes may be related to the improvement of stretch - shortening cycle movement performance after plyometric training. Through these findings, the study provides new insights into understanding how plyometric training improves joint stiffness and movement performance.