Abstract:Creating and evaluating predictions are considered important features in sensory perception. Little is known about processing differences between the senses and their cortical substrates. Here, we tested the hypothesis that olfaction, the sense of smell, would be highly dependent on (non-olfactory) object-predictive cues and involve distinct cortical processing features. We developed a novel paradigm to compare prediction error processing across senses. Participants listened to spoken word cues (e.g. “lilac”) and determined whether target stimuli (odors or pictures) matched the word cue or not. In two behavioral experiments (total n = 113; 72 female), the disparity between congruent and incongruent response-times was exaggerated for olfactory relative to visual targets, indicating a greater dependency on predictive verbal cues to process olfactory targets. A pre-registered fMRI study (n = 30; 19 female) revealed the anterior cingulate cortex (a region central for error detection) being more activated by incongruent olfactory targets, indicating a role for olfactory predictive error processing. Additionally, both the primary olfactory and visual cortices were significantly activated for incongruent olfactory targets, suggesting olfactory prediction errors are dependent on cross-sensory processing resources, whereas visual prediction errors are not. We propose that olfaction is characterized by a strong dependency on predictive (non-olfactory) cues, and that odors are evaluated in the context of such predictions by a designated transmodal cortical network. Our results indicate differences in how predictive cues are used by different senses in rapid decision-making. Significance Statement Evaluating predictions is regarded as a fundamental feature of the brain, but evidence is based mostly on visual stimuli. The sense of smell, olfaction, may thus differ from the visual system, but there are no direct comparisons. We show that behaviorally, olfaction relies more than vision on predictive cues when processing perceptual objects (e.g. seeing or smelling lilac and classifying it as such). In a follow-up, pre-registered fMRI experiment, we show that olfactory error signals activate a transmodal cortical network involving primary olfactory and visual cortices, as well as the anterior cingulate cortex. We suggest that human olfaction, due to its limited unisensory cortical resources, is dependent on a transmodal cortical error detection system.

Preprocessing of emotional visual information in the human piriform cortex

Single-neuron representations of odours in the human brain

Differences in the central-nervous processing of olfactory stimuli according to their hedonic and arousal characteristics

Gender Differences in the Processing of Standard Emotional Visual Stimuli: Integrating ERP and Fmri Results

Layer-specific, retinotopically-diffuse modulation in human visual cortex by emotional faces

An extremely fast neural mechanism to detect emotional visual stimuli: A two-experiment study

Sensory encoding of emotion conveyed by the face and visual context

Monorhinal and Birhinal Odor Processing in Humans: an fMRI investigation

Different Representations of Pleasant and Unpleasant Odours in the Human Brain.

Odor-evoked hedonic contexts influence the discrimination of facial expressions in the human brain

Unisensory visual and auditory objects are processed in olfactory cortex, independently of odor association

Convergence of Sensory Systems in the Orbitofrontal Cortex in Primates and Brain Design for Emotion

The human olfactory bulb communicates perceived odor valence to the piriform cortex in the gamma band and receives a refined representation back in the beta band

Neural basis of affective visual processing for fearful scenes

Olfactory categorization is shaped by a transmodal cortical network for evaluating perceptual predictions

Disentangling brain activity related to the processing of emotional visual information and emotional arousal

Decoding Multivoxel Representations of Affective Scenes in Retinotopic Visual Cortex

Investigating the Neural Correlates of Processing Basic Emotions: A Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS) Study

Insular dichotomy in the implicit detection of emotions in human faces

Human Brain Function during Odor Encoding and Recognition: A PET Activation Study a

An fMRI-based investigation of the effects of odors on the functional connectivity network underlying the working memory