Abstract:The computational modeling of chromatin structure is highly complex and challenging due to the hierarchical organization of chromatin, which reflects its diverse biophysical principles, as well as inherent dynamism, which underlies its complexity. The variety of methods for chromatin structure modeling, which are based on different approaches, assumptions and scales of modeling, suggests that there is a necessity for a comprehensive benchmark. This inspired us to conduct a project at the NIH-funded 4D Nucleome Hackathon on March 18-21, 2024 at The University of Washington in Seattle, USA. The hackathon provided an amazing opportunity to gather an international, multi-institutional and unbiased group of experts to discuss, understand and undertake the challenges of chromatin model comparison and validation. These challenges seem straightforward in theory, however in practice, they are challenging and ambiguous. To address them, we developed a bioinformatics workflow for chromatin model comparison and validation, in which we use distance matrices to represent chromatin models, and we calculate Spearman correlation coefficients between pairs of matrices to estimate correlations between models, as well as between models and experimental data. During the 4-day hackathon, we tested our workflow on several distinct software packages for chromatin structure modeling and we discovered several challenges that include: 1) different aspects of chromatin biophysics and scales complicate model comparisons, 2) expertise in biology, bioinformatics, and physics is necessary to conduct a comprehensive research on chromatin structure, 3) bioinformatic software, which is often developed in academic settings, is characterized by insufficient support and documentation. Therefore, our work constitutes a way to advance the modeling of the 3D organization of the human genome, while emphasizing the importance of establishing guidelines for software development and standardization.

The 4D nucleome project

Spatial and Temporal Organization of the Genome: Current State and Future Aims of the 4D Nucleome Project

An integrated view of the structure and function of the human 4D nucleome

4D nucleome: dynamic three-dimensional genome organization over time

OpenNucleome for high-resolution nuclear structural and dynamical modeling

OpenNucleome for high resolution nuclear structural and dynamical modeling

The genome in space and time comes of age

The‬‭ challenge‬‭ of‬‭ chromatin‬‭ model‬‭ comparison‬‭ and‬‭ validation‬‭ a‬‭ project‬‭ from‬‭ the‬ first international 4D Nucleome Hackathon‬

Mapping 3D genome organization relative to nuclear compartments using TSA-Seq as a cytological ruler

Chromatin tracing and multiplexed imaging of nucleome architectures (MINA) and RNAs in single mammalian cells and tissue

Chromatin architecture mapping by multiplex proximity tagging

Mapping the nuclear landscape with multiplexed super-resolution fluorescence microscopy

Methods for mapping 3D chromosome architecture

An Integrated 3-Dimensional Genome Modeling Engine for Data-Driven Simulation of Spatial Genome Organization.

ChromEMT: visualizing and reconstructing chromatin ultrastructure and 3D organization in situ

Understanding 3D genome organization by multidisciplinary methods

4D nucleome equation predicts gene expression controlled by long-range enhancer-promoter interaction

ChromEMT: Visualizing 3D chromatin structure and compaction in interphase and mitotic cells

The era of 3D and spatial genomics

DNA O-MAP uncovers the molecular neighborhoods associated with specific genomic loci