The Impacts of Markets and Tax on a Multinational Firm's Procurement Strategy in China

Jiayan Xu,Vernon N. Hsu,Baozhuang Niu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.12798

IF: 4.638

2017-11-01

Production and Operations Management

Abstract:Motivated by observations in the greater China region, this paper studies a multinational firm (MNF)'s preferences between two procurement strategies in a global business environment. The MNF relies on a contract manufacturer (CM) to produce its products, which serve both markets within (domestic market) and outside (overseas market) China. The MNF is assumed to be monopolistic in the overseas market but faces competition from a local original equipment manufacturer (OEM) who outsources both manufacturing and component procurement to the CM. The MNF will decide whether to control its component procurement (consignment strategy) or delegate that function to the CM (turnkey strategy). Our study indicates that a number of factors unique to the global supply chain environment, such as a multi‐market structure with different sizes and natures of competition, and a set of tax rules that gives differential treatment to products serving different markets, have the potential of impacting the MNF's choice of consignment vs. turnkey strategies, sometimes in interesting ways. In particular, we find that when attempting to balance the pros and cons of cooperating with the local OEM under turnkey while competing against it in the domestic market, the MNF's preference could switch twice from turnkey to consignment and back to turnkey, and its global profits could first decrease and then increase, as the domestic market grows. Our study also highlights the importance of making a company's global supply chain management decisions while considering international tax rules.

operations research & management science,engineering, manufacturing

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the complex decision - making problem of multinational corporations (MNFs) in the choice of procurement strategies in China's multi - market environment. Specifically, the paper explores how multinational corporations choose between turnkey procurement and consignment procurement in the face of competition of different scales and natures in the domestic and overseas markets, as well as differences in China's import and export tax policies. The study finds that with the growth of the domestic market, the preferences of multinational corporations may shift from one strategy to another, and may even change multiple times, depending on the relative size and competition situation of the market. In addition, the study also emphasizes the importance of international tax rules in global supply chain management decisions.

The paper analyzes the impact of these factors on procurement strategies by constructing a model with four participants - local component suppliers (SP), local contract manufacturers (CM), local original equipment manufacturers (OEM) that only sell products in the domestic market, and multinational corporations (MNF) that sell products in both domestic and overseas markets. The model considers the impact of market structure, tax policies, and the cooperation and competition relationship (the so - called "co - opetition" relationship) between multinational corporations and local OEMs on the choice of procurement strategies of multinational corporations.

Key findings include:
- When the domestic market is relatively small or large, multinational corporations are more inclined to adopt the turnkey procurement strategy; when the domestic market is similar in size to the overseas market, they are more inclined to adopt the consignment procurement strategy.
- With the growth of the domestic market, multinational corporations may experience two transitions from turnkey procurement to consignment procurement and then back to turnkey procurement.
- China's import and export tax policies have a significant impact on the procurement decisions of multinational corporations. In particular, changes in the value - added tax (VAT) refund rate will affect the profitability of multinational corporations in domestic and overseas markets, thereby affecting their choice of procurement strategies.

These findings are of great significance for understanding the supply chain management strategies of multinational corporations in the context of globalization, especially in a rapidly developing market like China.