Cultures of Mixing: Understanding Partnerships Across Ethnicity
Chamion Caballero,Rosalind Edwards,Darren Smith
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17450140701749171
2008-01-01
Abstract:This article presents an extensive analysis of 'cultures of mixing'―that is, relationships between partners from different ethnic backgrounds―based on 2001 British census data. The data is used to show how 'mixed' partnerships are relevant to aspects of current debates about the nature of ethnic relations in contemporary Britain. We begin with a discussion of dominant stereotypes around mixed race/ethnicity partnerships in Britain and their links to dystopian visions of majority and minority ethnic relations, before looking at frameworks of understanding that offer a challenge to these gloomy diagnoses, and in particular the concept of 'convivial culture'. This discussion is followed by an analysis of the location and socio-economic characteristics of 'cultures of mixing'. We argue that 'cultures of mixing' are spatially and socially uneven, and appear to be underpinned by more material and equity-based features of social life and provision. Notes 1. There are debates about the most appropriate terminology to use: mixed race, mixed ethnicity, mixed heritage, dual heritage, multiple heritage and so on, e.g. discussions in Barn & Harman Citation(2005); Wright et al. Citation(2003). In this paper we predominantly use the term 'mixed' as it allows us to highlight the processes of mixing central to our arguments, and reflects official Census terminology (see footnote 4) as well as common usage by many 'mixed' couples and individuals themselves (Caballero, Edwards & Puthussery, work in progress). 2. Although on mainland Britain 'mixed' relationships are commonly understood to refer to race and ethnicity (our topic of discussion here), in the Northern Ireland context it has more conventionally meant partnerships between Catholics and Protestants (see for example Morgan et al., Citation1996), albeit this may change as Northern Ireland is becoming more racially and ethnically diverse. Our thanks to one of the referees of this paper for pointing this out to us. 3. The Guardian, 22 May 1997; Mail on Sunday, 8 December 2002. 4. Sources: Berrington Citation(1996); Census, April, 2001, ONS. 5. Source: Census, April, 2001, ONS. The new 'Mixed' category varied slightly depending on the regional census in which it appeared. The 2001 English and Welsh censuses offered a choice of four options within the Mixed category—White and Black Caribbean, White and Black African, White and Asian, and Any Other Mixed Background—whilst the 2001 Scottish and Northern Irish censuses both offered free text write-in options under the respective categories of 'Any Mixed Background' and 'Mixed ethnic group'. The total number of 'Mixed' respondents is based on responses to the overall 'Mixed' category in each census (Caballero, Citation2005). 6. 'Parenting Mixed Heritage Children: Negotiating Difference and Belonging' is funded by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. The project also includes mixed faith relationships, where parents are from different religious backgrounds, but we do not discuss this aspect here. 7. A mirror image to the 'hybrid degeneration' argument is that of hybrid vigour, where mixed race people are seen as embodying the best of both races in terms of physical condition (Caballero, Citation2005). While equally dangerous, the notion of hybrid vigour is still muted in comparison. 8. The spaces where partners from different racial and ethnic backgrounds meet is receiving attention in the US context (e.g. Houston et al., Citation2005) and this endeavour potentially provides a valuable addition to conceptions of the locations for convivial culture and ideas about multicultural public space. However, it is not our concern here. 9. Here we are concerned with extensive cultures of mixing. Our subsequent work will enable us to describe processes: variable intensive cultures of mixing in how couples from different racial/ethnic backgrounds live out their mixedness in bringing up their children to have a sense of identity and belonging. 10. It is possible that some parents of mixed ethnicity children may not share the same place of residence, or their partnership may have been severed since the birth of their mixed ethnicity child/ren. Nonetheless, this variable does provide a measure of the magnitude and geographies of mixed ethnicity partnerships in England and Wales. 11. Analyses of the data using Mapinfo GIS showed the top 50 as a natural break within the data for identifying 'hotspots' of mixed race and ethnicity partnerships within England and Wales. 12. Subject to more rigorous analysis, it is our impression from the intensive qualitative phase of our research that bringing up their children in a racially and ethnically diverse area is often important to the mixed couple parents we have interviewed. 13. Indeed, John Stillwell & Deborah Phillips (2006) argue that we know little about how minority ethnic spatial distributions are evolving, and that this requires urgent research attention.