Abstract:Objective: Intersection crashes resulted in over 5,000 fatalities in the United States in 2014. Intersection Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (I-ADAS) are active safety systems that seek to help drivers safely traverse intersections. I-ADAS uses onboard sensors to detect oncoming vehicles and, in the event of an imminent crash, can either alert the driver or take autonomous evasive action. The objective of this study was to develop and evaluate a predictive model for detecting whether a stop sign violation was imminent. Methods: Passenger vehicle intersection approaches were extracted from a data set of typical driver behavior (100-Car Naturalistic Driving Study) and violations (event data recorders downloaded from real-world crashes) and were assigned weighting factors based on real-world frequency. A k-fold cross-validation procedure was then used to develop and evaluate 3 hypothetical stop sign warning algorithms (i.e., early, intermediate, and delayed) for detecting an impending violation during the intersection approach. Violation detection models were developed using logistic regression models that evaluate likelihood of a violation at various locations along the intersection approach. Two potential indicators of driver intent to stop-that is, required deceleration parameter (RDP) and brake application-were used to develop the predictive models. The earliest violation detection opportunity was then evaluated for each detection algorithm in order to (1) evaluate the violation detection accuracy and (2) compare braking demand versus maximum braking capabilities. Results: A total of 38 violating and 658 nonviolating approaches were used in the analysis. All 3 algorithms were able to detect a violation at some point during the intersection approach. The early detection algorithm, as designed, was able to detect violations earlier than all other algorithms during the intersection approach but gave false alarms for 22.3% of approaches. In contrast, the delayed detection algorithm sacrificed some time for detecting violations but was able to substantially reduce false alarms to only 3.3% of all nonviolating approaches. Given good surface conditions (maximum braking capabilities = 0.8 g) and maximum effort, most drivers (55.3-71.1%) would be able to stop the vehicle regardless of the detection algorithm. However, given poor surface conditions (maximum braking capabilities = 0.4 g), few drivers (10.5-26.3%) would be able to stop the vehicle. Automatic emergency braking (AEB) would allow for early braking prior to driver reaction. If equipped with an AEB system, the results suggest that, even for the poor surface conditions scenario, over one half (55.3-65.8%) of the vehicles could have been stopped. Conclusions: This study demonstrates the potential of I-ADAS to incorporate a stop sign violation detection algorithm. Repeating the analysis on a larger, more extensive data set will allow for the development of a more comprehensive algorithm to further validate the findings.

A Novel Surrogate Safety Indicator Based on Constant Initial Acceleration and Reaction Time Assumption

Safety Evaluation for Expressways: A Comparative Study for Macroscopic and Microscopic Indicators

Assessing Surrogate Safety Measures using a Safety Pilot Model Deployment Dataset

Evaluation of Conventional Surrogate Indicators of Safety for Connected and Automated Vehicles in Car Following at Signalized Intersections

Novel Crash Surrogate Measure for Freeways

Performance evaluation of surrogate measures of safety with naturalistic driving data

A Driving Risk Surrogate and Its Application in Car-Following Scenario at Expressway

Anticipated buffer time - An evasive surrogate safety indicator for risk assessment of unsignalized intersections under heterogeneous traffic and aggressive driving conditions

Validating A Driving Simulator Using Surrogate Safety Measures

Surrogate safety measures for traffic oscillations based on empirical vehicle trajectories prior to crashes

Quantification of Rear-End Crash Risk and Analysis of Its Influencing Factors Based on a New Surrogate Safety Measure

Surrogate Safety Measure for Simulation-Based Conflict Study

Traffic Safety Evaluation of Uncontrolled Intersections using Surrogate Safety Measures under Mixed Traffic Conditions

What do surrogate safety metrics measure? Understanding driving safety as a continuum

An NCAP-like Safety Indicator for Self-Driving Cars

A Crash Surrogate Metric Considering Traffic Flow Dynamics in a Motorway Corridor

Speed Reduction Measure Based on Nudging Using Real-Time Vehicle Trajectory Acquisition With Thermal Cameras

SafeDrive: A New Model for Driving Risk Analysis Based on Crash Avoidance

Integrated driving risk surrogate model and car-following behavior for freeway risk assessment

A Crash Risk Identification Method for Freeway Segments with Horizontal Curvature Based on Real-Time Vehicle Kinetic Response

Predicting crash-relevant violations at stop sign-controlled intersections for the development of an intersection driver assistance system