Abstract:Background: Despite evidence that synthetic phonics teaching has increased reading attainments, a sizable minority of children struggle to acquire phonics skills and teachers lack clear principles for deciding what types of additional support are most beneficial. Synthetic phonics teaches children to read using a decoding strategy to translate letters into sounds and blend them (e.g., c-a-t = "k - ae - t" = "cat"). To use a decoding strategy, children require letter-sound knowledge (LSK) and the ability to blend sound units (phonological awareness; PA). Training on PA has been shown to benefit struggling beginning readers. However, teachers in English primary schools do not routinely check PA. Instead, struggling beginner readers usually receive additional LSK support. Aims: Until now, there has been no systematic comparison of the effectiveness of training on each component of the decoding process. Should additional support for struggling readers focus on improving PA, or on supplementary LSK and/or decoding instruction? We aim to increase understanding of the roles of LSK and PA in children's acquisition of phonics skills and uncover which types of additional training are most likely to be effective for struggling beginner readers. Sample and method: We will compare training on each of these components, using a carefully controlled experimental design. We will identify reception-age children at risk of reading difficulties (target n = 225) and randomly allocate them to either PA, LSK or decoding (DEC) training. We will test whether training type influences post-test performance on word reading and whether any effects depend on participants' pre-test PA and/or LSK. Results and conclusions: Two hundred and twenty-two participants completed the training. Planned analyses showed no effects of condition on word reading. However, exploratory analyses indicated that the advantage of trained over untrained words was significantly greater for the PA and DEC conditions. There was also a significantly greater improvement in PA for the DEC condition. Overall, our findings suggest a potential advantage of training that includes blending skills, particularly when decoding words that had been included in training. Future research is needed to develop a programme of training on blending skills combined with direct vocabulary instruction for struggling beginner readers.

Beginning Literacy: The Small-Unit Versus Large-Unit Debate Continues

Reconsidering the Evidence That Systematic Phonics Is More Effective Than Alternative Methods of Reading Instruction

Maximizing Small‐Group Reading Instruction

Systematic Phonics Instruction Helps Students Learn to Read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel’s Meta-Analysis

The Effect of Phonemic Awareness on the Literacy Development of First Grade Children in a Traditional or a Whole Language Classroom

An experimental comparison of additional training in phoneme awareness, letter-sound knowledge and decoding for struggling beginner readers

A Commentary on Bowers (2020) and the Role of Phonics Instruction in Reading

Beyond Phonics: The Case for Teaching Children the Logic of the English Spelling System

There is still little or no evidence that systematic phonics is more effective than common alternative methods of reading instruction: Response to Brooks (2023)

The Science of Learning to Read Words: A Case for Systematic Phonics Instruction

The linguistic base of initial reading and spelling in English: a tutorial review

Beginning literacy: links among teacher knowledge, teacher practice, and student learning

Effective Reading Programs for the Elementary Grades: A Best-Evidence Synthesis

The National Literacy Strategy and dyslexia: a Comparison of Teaching Methods and Materials

The importance of correctly characterising the English spelling system when devising and evaluating methods of reading instruction: Comment on Taylor, Davis, and Rastle (2017)

Visual and phonological processing of words: a comparison of good and poor readers

Systematic phonics instruction belongs in evidence-based reading programs: A response to Bowers

Trends in the Selection of Primary Grade (K-3) Reading Programs and Assessments in the United States

Reading Aloud and First Language Development: A Systematic Review

An Adequate Model for the Development of English Reading Skills

African American English and Early Literacy: A Comparison of Approaches to Quantifying Nonmainstream Dialect Use