Abstract:Background: Acute respiratory infections are a common reason for consultation with primary and emergency healthcare services. Identifying individuals with a bacterial infection is crucial to ensure appropriate treatment. However, it is also important to avoid overprescription of antibiotics, to prevent unnecessary side effects and antimicrobial resistance. We conducted a systematic review to summarise evidence on the diagnostic accuracy of symptoms, signs and point-of-care tests to diagnose bacterial respiratory tract infection in adults, and to diagnose two common respiratory viruses, influenza and respiratory syncytial virus. Methods: The primary approach was an overview of existing systematic reviews. We conducted literature searches (22 May 2023) to identify systematic reviews of the diagnostic accuracy of point-of-care tests. Where multiple reviews were identified, we selected the most recent and comprehensive review, with the greatest overlap in scope with our review question. Methodological quality was assessed using the Risk of Bias in Systematic Reviews tool. Summary estimates of diagnostic accuracy (sensitivity, specificity or area under the curve) were extracted. Where no systematic review was identified, we searched for primary studies. We extracted sufficient data to construct a 2 × 2 table of diagnostic accuracy, to calculate sensitivity and specificity. Methodological quality was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies version 2 tool. Where possible, meta-analyses were conducted. We used GRADE to assess the certainty of the evidence from existing reviews and new analyses. Results: We identified 23 reviews which addressed our review question; 6 were selected as the most comprehensive and similar in scope to our review protocol. These systematic reviews considered the following tests for bacterial respiratory infection: individual symptoms and signs; combinations of symptoms and signs (in clinical prediction models); clinical prediction models incorporating C-reactive protein; and biological markers related to infection (including C-reactive protein, procalcitonin and others). We also identified systematic reviews that reported the accuracy of specific tests for influenza and respiratory syncytial virus. No reviews were found that assessed the diagnostic accuracy of white cell count for bacterial respiratory infection, or multiplex tests for influenza and respiratory syncytial virus. We therefore conducted searches for primary studies, and carried out meta-analyses for these index tests. Overall, we found that symptoms and signs have poor diagnostic accuracy for bacterial respiratory infection (sensitivity ranging from 9.6% to 89.1%; specificity ranging from 13.4% to 95%). Accuracy of biomarkers was slightly better, particularly when combinations of biomarkers were used (sensitivity 80-90%, specificity 82-93%). The sensitivity and specificity for influenza or respiratory syncytial virus varied considerably across the different types of tests. Tests involving nucleic acid amplification techniques (either single pathogen or multiplex tests) had the highest diagnostic accuracy for influenza (sensitivity 91-99.8%, specificity 96.8-99.4%). Limitations: Most of the evidence was considered low or very low certainty when assessed with GRADE, due to imprecision in effect estimates, the potential for bias and the inclusion of participants outside the scope of this review (children, or people in hospital). Future work: Currently evidence is insufficient to support routine use of point-of-care tests in primary and emergency care. Further work must establish whether the introduction of point-of-care tests adds value, or simply increases healthcare costs. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR159948.

Point-of-care diagnostics for respiratory viral infections

Advanced Point‐of‐Care Testing Technologies for Human Acute Respiratory Virus Detection

The impact of commercial rapid respiratory virus diagnostic tests on patient outcomes and health system utilization

Diagnostic accuracy of point-of-care tests for acute respiratory infection: a systematic review of reviews

Point-of-Care Multiplex Detection of Respiratory Viruses

Usefulness of Point-of-Care Testing for Respiratory Viruses in a Pediatric Emergency Department Setting

Diagnostic and economic evaluation of a point-of-care test for respiratory syncytial virus

Rapid antigen-based testing for respiratory syncytial virus: moving diagnostics from bench to bedside?

Rapid and simple molecular tests for the detection of respiratory syncytial virus: a review

Clinical Status and Challenges of Respiratory Virus Rapid Detection

Point-of-care tests for infection control: should rapid testing be in the laboratory or at the front line?

Influenza viruses and SARS-CoV-2 diagnosis via sensitive testing methods in clinical application

Clinical impact of rapid molecular diagnostic tests in patients presenting with viral respiratory symptoms: A systematic literature review

Point-of-Care Diagnostics of COVID-19: From Current Work to Future Perspectives

Prospective Evaluation of Rapid Antigen Tests for Diagnosis of Respiratory Viral Pathogens.

Recent advances in the detection of respiratory virus infection in humans

Recent Progress on Rapid Diagnosis of COVID-19 by Point-of-care Testing Platforms.

Detection of Influenza A and B Viruses and Respiratory Syncytial Virus by Use of Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments of 1988 (CLIA)-Waived Point-of-Care Assays: a Paradigm Shift to Molecular Tests

Development of a self-contained microfluidic chip and an internet-of-things-based point-of-care device for automated identification of respiratory viruses

Summarizing Study Characteristics and Diagnostic Performance of Commercially Available Tests for Respiratory Syncytial Virus: A Scoping Literature Review in the COVID-19 Era

Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for identifying acute viral upper respiratory tract infections