Weighted citation based on ranking-related contribution: a new index for evaluating article impact
Yuanyuan Liu,Qiang Wu,Shijie Wu,Yong Gao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-021-04115-6
IF: 3.801
2021-08-18
Scientometrics
Abstract:Citation count fails to comprehensively and accurately portray the publication's impact, and the scientific impact is far more than what we see on the surface. This paper proposes a new impact indicator, the Contribution-Weighted Citation index, in which each citation is weighted from the perspective of the citing item. The method of weighting is based on ranking of the 'old' impact values of articles published in the same year and same field, and modifies the value of one citation from each publication positively or negatively. The idea of iteration is introduced into the calculation process for more accurate results. We empirically analysed 3,847,243 papers from the WoS database for the 1978–2017 period, including the fields of Mathematics, Physics, and Space Science. The experimental results show that the three variants of the new index proposed in this article show different characteristics in identifying article impact. Our new indicator in sine mode make articles more discrete, which helps distinguish between papers with similar citation count, while the arcsine mode is more helpful to identify high-citation-quality papers. In addition, we found the average citation quality of lowly cited papers fluctuates greatly, and some such papers have surprisingly high citation quality; for highly cited case, the average citation quality stabilizes in a certain range. This article has a positive role in identifying important publications and under-cited publications.
information science & library science,computer science, interdisciplinary applications