Abstract:The paper discusses the theory of relevance, advanced in the middle of the 1980s by Dan Sperber and Deidra Wilson, in the context of opposition between the proponents of “ideal language philosophy”, or formal semantics, and adherents of “ordinary language philosophy”. Though the theory was created as a version of cognitive pragmatics, an area at the junction of cognitive sciences and theoretical linguistics, it is of undoubted interest for philosophical comprehension of language, verbal communication, and the nature of meaning. Treating verbal communication as a cognitive process, Sperber and Wilson formulate the two most important principles underlying the process – the cognitive principle of relevance and the communicative principle of relevance. The paper explains the basic notions of the theory – ostensive communication, informative and communicative intentions, optimal relevance, explicature; it reveals the advantages that the authors of the theory see in the “inferential” model of communication over the “code” model and discusses how they present the process of understanding a speaker’s utterance by a hearer on the “implicit” and “explicit” levels and what role in the process they ascribe to pragmatic inferences. The account of the relevance theory is accompanied by its comparison with the picture of verbal communication elaborated by Paul Grice, and it is shown that though Sperber and Wilson make a start from Grice’s ideas in many respects, they introduce significant alterations and so they are regarded as representatives of post-Gricean pragmatics. In conclusion, it is examined how, according to the relevance theory, the semantics/pragmatics distinction should be drawn. It is discussed how the proposed decision alters the understanding of the nature of meaning and what consequences it has for philosophy.

Larisa Maksimova’s Early Contributions to Relevance Logic

Reflections on the Relevance Logic

Topics, Non-Uniform Substitutions, and Variable Sharing

Algorithmic correspondence for relevance logics, bunched implication logics, and relation algebras: the algorithm PEARL and its implementation (Technical Report)

An Explanation for the Ternary Relation R in the Relational Semantics of Relevance Logic

An Explanation for the Relational Semantics of Relevance Logic

The relevance theory, pragmatics and the problem of meaning

Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Multiplicative Linear Logic (Extended Abstract)

A logic of judgmental existence and its relation to proof irrelevance

Adding an Implication to Logics of Perfect Paradefinite Algebras

A Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Linear Logic

Logics of polyhedral reachability

Reasoning with belief functions over Belnap--Dunn logic

A Note on an Inferentialist Approach to Resource Semantics

Founded Semantics and Constraint Semantics of Logic Rules

Implicitly Learning to Reason in First-Order Logic

Inferentialist Resource Semantics

Learning from Łukasiewicz and Meredith: Investigations into Proof Structures (Extended Version)

Benthem Logic and Reasoning : do the facts matter ?

Relevance in Structured Argumentation