Comprehensive Assessment of Urban Ecological Risks:The Case of Huaibei City
ZHANG Xiaofei,WANG Rusong,LI Zhengguo,LI Feng,WU Jiansheng,HUANG Jinlou,YU Yingying
2011-01-01
Abstract:Ecological risk is defined as the probability that a specific population,landscape,or ecosystem in a dangerous environment has its health,productivity,hereditary features,or economic and aesthetic values affected.Various and complex ecological risks occur widely in urban ecosystem.Conventional assessments for single types of ecological risks are not comprehensive enough to evaluate the degree of ecological risk,and are also unsuitable to meet the multiple needs of sustainable urban development and management.In this paper,a research framework has been formulated to evaluate urban ecological risks spatially and more comprehensively.The framework has five steps: identification of potential risk types,selection of influential factors,exposure analysis,effect analysis,and putting forward of mitigation measures. First,three primary kinds of ecological risks,including natural disasters,environmental pollution,and ecological degeneration are considered.Selecting factors of the natural environment,social economy,landscape,and pollution would be used to explain the influence of spatial characteristics.Exposure analysis showed frequency,range,and duration of each risk based on the weather record,Annual Report of Environment Quality,and other statistical data from government departments. The effect analysis integrated the results of exposure degree,effect of environmental factors,and degree of vulnerability.Degree of vulnerability depends on risk object characteristics.Land use unit is suitable to be the object for illustrating the degree of risk influence directly and linking with urban planning.Considering function and land cover,land use types would be categorized as high density building area,medium density building area,low density building area,traffic land,forest land,grassland,cultivated land,garden land,water,and unused land. The urban core area of Huaibei city has been chosen to test this framework.Major ecological risks in Huaibei include flood,drought,water pollution,air pollution,land subsidence,and ecological service degradation.Single and comprehensive ecological risk degrees have been calculated.Based on these,spatial strategies of urban ecological planning are proposed that incorporate these assessment results.Three risk levels were recognized in this study area by our comprehensive ecological risk assessment.In high risk areas land use for urban expansion and construction should be limited in future planning,vegetation cover should be restored,and climate change and environmental quality should be monitored to protect the urban ecological environment and the lives and health of human beings.Medium risk areas require a different building code for each risk category when building and constructing to ensure the safety of infrastructure such as traffic,energy,and water.Furthermore,an environmental impact assessment should be undertaken and approved to guide building.High density development should be limited to low risk areas,although the need for land use management after planning remains. The framework of comprehensive ecological risk assessment integrated different risks of natural disasters,environmental pollution,and ecological degeneration.Land use units have been used as the risk objects and which can be directly used as the ecological background for urban planning in the future.Also,it is simple to adjust when land use changes,and when different planning scenarios require new decisions.Furthermore,it can highlight spatial variation of ecological risks and make suggestions for efficient mitigation.There are still some difficulties in the study,i.e.the considerations of the degree of vulnerability are complicated,and have to integrate the opinions of experts,local residents,and governments.For governments,the degree of vulnerability is linked with financial expenditure;for residents,it depends on the safety of life and belongings;and for different experts,it involves natural capital,environmental quality,human health,and so on.