Abstract:The paper describes how, in the context of the development of the French human sciences (sciences de l'homme) around 1800, the reference to the Reign of Terror was constitutive for the formulation and legitimation of a procedure, which was based on what Jean-Étienne Esquirol called "moral shocks" (sécousse morale). The psychiatric and pedagogical discussion of non-physical effects on the spirit (esprit) of human subjects and patients essentially dealt with the question: could people have been liberated by the shocking surge of the Revolution from the demeaning and dependent habits of the Old Regime (ancien régime), or could this violent revolution have had a pathological effect? This article shows that, after 1800, the latter interpretation became accepted. A professional self-image of psychiatric and pedagogical expertise formed in the relationship between physician and patient or teacher and student. This expertise justified employing shocks in professionally controlled settings, while the healing power of the revolutionary was negated. This article thereby distinguishes between four different perspectives on the pathological or healing effect of what was perceived as a "revolutionary shock": firstly, a positive perspective that interprets the shock of the Revolution as healthy, stimulating the vital forces of the people languishing in inactivity; secondly, a cautious perspective that emphasizes the necessity of curbing and controlling the passions of the people; thirdly, a perspective that recognizes in the outburst of passions an aberration from the natural state, and fourthly, a therapeutic perspective that recommends the use of passions by experts in very controlled spaces. Based on published texts and material from the Archives nationales as well as the Institut national de jeunes sourds, this article provides a political history of the development of moral shocks and argues that the development of epistemological and therapeutic technologies in the human sciences were essentially the result of a demarcation from revolutionary violence as well as the desire in the human sciences for a stable government.

The homeless heritage of the French Revolution, c.1789–1889

Finding the American Revolution in France: François-Jean de Chastellux's Private Papers and Beyond

Cultural Revolutions: Everyday Life and Politics in Britain, North America and France. By Leora Auslander. (Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 2009. Pp.xii, 243. $19.95.)

A Sense of a European Present and its Passing during the Revolutions of 1848

Cosmography, Local History, and National Sentiment: François de Belleforest and the History of Paris

The Paris Commune in the British socialist imagination, 1871–1914

The curator, the investor, and the dupe: Consumer desire and Chinese Cultural Revolution memorabilia

Counter-revolutionary culture

Individuals, Institutions, and Innovation in the Debates of the French Revolution

The Facets of the Enlightenment Movement from a Libertarian Perspective:

‘Come and Dine’: The Dangers of Conspicuous Consumption in French Revolutionary Politics, 1789–95

Archives, Memories, and Masks in Writing the History of the French Resistance

[The French Revolution as Moral Shock : On the Political Dimension of the Research and Therapy of the Human Mind, ca. 1792-1806]

Remembering Hope: Transnational activism beyond the traumatic

Old French and new money: Jews and the aesthetics of the Old Regime in transnational perspective, c.1860–1910

Notre-Dame as the Memory of Paris: Hugo, the Historical Novel and Conservation

Restitution of cultural property: the rise and fall of a cosmopolitan ideal

In Quest of the Antique: The Bazaar, Exchange and Mart and the Democratization of Collecting, 1926-42

Imagining an Old City in Nineteenth-Century France: Urban Renovation, Civil Society, and the Making of Vieux Lyon

Revolution and counter-revolution; or why it is difficult to have a heritage of communism and what can we do about it

The 1848 Revolution and the Rise of Nationalism in France