Converging Precincts: Sociology and Sherlock Holmes

Ketaki Dwivedi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0038022917751978

2018-02-13

Sociological Bulletin

Abstract:The article using literary texts attempts to draw similarities in the trajectories of emergences and concerns of the 19th-century sociology and crime/detection fiction represented in particular by Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes. It attempts to contextualise the conditions of emergences, common intellectual moorings and their negotiations with similar themes in the domain of modern rational science discourse and tenet, where everything was to be open to query and testing. The article proposes that the shared intellectual inspirations in science and reason, the engagements with positivism-empiricism and redressal of the disorder and anxiety that European society experienced at the time show that there are multi-level connections between the detective stories and science of society.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore the similarities and connections between sociology in the 19th century and detective novels (especially Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes series). Specifically, the author tries to analyze, through literary texts, the similarities between 19th - century sociology and crime/detective novels in terms of their emergence backgrounds, common intellectual foundations, and approaches to dealing with similar themes. The paper points out that these similarities are manifested in the following aspects:

1. **Emergence Background**: In the 19th century, Western society underwent the process of modernization, including technological development, the Industrial Revolution, population migration, urbanization, and the formation of nation - states. These changes not only affected the socio - economic structure but also led to profound changes in the cultural field, such as the rise of modernism. The rupture of social relations and the enhancement of individual consciousness in society became important characteristics of this period.

2. **Common Intellectual Foundation**: Both 19th - century sociology and detective novels were influenced by rationalism and scientific methods. For example, Auguste Comte's positivism emphasized obtaining knowledge through observation and experimentation, and this idea is also reflected in Sherlock Holmes' reasoning process. Sherlock Holmes' stories are full of observations of details and logical reasoning, which coincides with the empirical methods in sociological research.

3. **Treatment of Similar Themes**: Both are concerned with the maintenance of social order and the resolution of chaos. Sociologists attempt to explain the causes and consequences of social change, while detective novels restore social order by solving criminal cases. Sherlock Holmes' stories not only show how to solve problems through scientific methods but also reflect the society's belief in rationality, science, and progress at that time.

4. **Social Function**: The detective characters in detective novels are regarded as the guardians of society. They solve social problems and restore social order through their wisdom and skills. This is similar to the function of sociology, that is, to understand social phenomena through scientific research, propose solutions, and thus promote the stability and development of society.

In conclusion, by comparing the development of 19th - century sociology and detective novels, this paper reveals the multi - level connections between the two in terms of intellectual foundation, research methods, and dealing with social problems, and emphasizes their common roles in responding to social change and maintaining social order.