Abstract:Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have been gaining increasing popularity in the investment community as is evidenced by the high growth both in the number of ETFs and their net assets since 2000. As ETFs are in nature similar to index mutual funds, in this paper we examined if this growing demand for ETFs can be explained through their outperformance as compared to index mutual funds. We considered the population of all ETFs with inception dates prior to 2002 and then for each ETF found all the passive index mutual funds that had the same investment style as the selected ETF and had inception date prior to 2002. Within each investment style we matched every ETF with all the passive index funds in that investment style and compared the performances of the matched pairs in terms of Sharp Ratios and risk adjusted buy and hold total returns for the period 2002-2010. We then applied the Wilcoxon signed rank test to examine if ETFs had better performances than index mutual funds during the sample period. Out of the 230 paired matches of all the styles, ETFs outperformed index mutual funds in 134 of the times in terms of Sharpe Ratio, however, the test of the hypothesis showed no statistically significant difference between ETFs and index funds performances in terms of Sharpe ratio. Out of the 230 paired matches of all the styles, ETFs outperformed index mutual funds in 125 of the times in terms of risk adjusted buy and hold total return, however, the test of hypothesis showed no statistically significant difference between ETFs and index funds performances in terms of risk adjusted buy and hold total return. These findings indicate there is statistically no significant difference between ETFs and passive index mutual funds performances at the fund level and investors' choice between the two is related to product characteristics and tax advantages.

Innovation and Informed Trading: Evidence from Industry ETFs

Pricing Efficiency of China's Exchange-Traded Fund Market

On the Pricing Efficiency of China’s ETF Market

The Informational Role of Options Trading: Evidence from the Shanghai Stock Exchange 50ETF Options in China

ETF ownership and stock pricing efficiency: The role of ETF arbitrage

How Do Smart Beta ETFs Affect the Asset Management Industry? Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows

Do ETFs Improve the pricing efficiency of the A-share market—examining ETF holdings of individual stocks

The Unexpected Activeness of Passive Investors: A World-Wide Analysis of ETFs

Informed trading by hedge funds

The Effect of Liquidity and Arbitrage on the Price Efficiency of Chinese ETFs

An analytical performance comparison of exchanged traded funds with index funds: 2002-2010

ETF ownership and stock liquidity: evidence from China

Excess Return and Tracking Errors of Chinese ETFs

Can enhanced stock price informativeness improve the investment efficiency of Chinese listed companies?

Informed Futures Trading and Price Discovery: Evidence from Taiwan Futures and Stock Markets

Empirical Study on Price Discovery of Exchange Traded Fund in China

The Dark Side of ETF Investing: A World-Wide Analysis

Investor Limited Attention, Opinion Divergence, and Post-earnings-announcement Drift: Evidence from China

Sophisticated investors and market efficiency: Evidence from a natural experiment

Trading Frequency and Information Efficiency: Theory and Evidence from US and Chinese Markets

Extended Trading in Chinese Index Markets: Informed or Uninformed?