Abstract:INTRODUCTIONCurrent green building practice has been largely advanced by an integrated design process. This integrated design process involves multiple disciplines, such as architecture, civil, mechanical, and electrical engineering. The design method heavily relies on utilizing building performance simulation to illustrate how design parameters affect the energy consumption and quality of the indoor environment before actual design decisions are made (Anderson, 2014). The architectural design tools in the integrated design process supersede traditional geometrical exploration instruments, such as Sketchup, Revit, ArchiCad, and Rhino (Negendahl, 2015). More building performance simulating tools, such as Ecotect, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), Radiance, and EnergyPlus, have been developed to help architects measure building performance (e.g., natural ventilation, daylighting, solar radiation, and energy uses) in the design process and attain green building standards such as Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED). The information presented by these tools guide architects at a certain level in achieving green building goals. However, building simulation is generally beyond the architect's knowledge domain. Many architects have difficulty in understanding these technical terms and models, as well as their design implications. Therefore, specific consultants have emerged to help architects grasp the meanings of these numbers and models, which require architects to implement a high level of design collaboration and coordination (Aksamija, 2015; Gou & Lau, 2014). Simulation consultants can work in parallel with architects at the early design stage to intervene in the conceptual and schematic design; they may also work behind architects to verify the building performance after the design is finished and make their design green through technical alterations.Most existing literature argues for an early intervention of building performance simulation in the architectural design process and explores different algorithms or models for optimal intervention (Degens, Scholzen, & Odenbreit, 2015; Sick, Schade, Mourtada, Uh, & Grausam, 2014; Svetlana Olbina & Yvan Beliveau, 2007). However, the difference between early intervention and late verification is often not investigated. Few qualitative studies can help understand how the building performance simulation is actually implemented, and how it influences the quality of design solutions in addition to the quantity of performance outcomes. The current research presents two case studies that compare building performance simulation as an early intervention and a late verification tool in the architectural design process, which contextualizes the building simulation research in real building practices.

Performer, consumer or expert? A critical review of building performance simulation training paradigms for building design decision-making

Performance Simulation Integrated in Parametric 3D Modeling as a Method for Early Stage Design Optimization—A Review

Building performance with an integrated simulation approach: Experiences in Solar Decathlon Europe 21/22 and future perspectives

Teaching building performance simulation: Considerations on methodologies and course levels

Building Energy Simulation and Its Application for Building Performance Optimization: A Review of Methods, Tools, and Case Studies

Teaching Sustainable Design Using BIM and Project-Based Energy Simulations

BUILDING PERFORMANCE SIMULATION AS AN EARLY INTERVENTION OR LATE VERIFICATION IN ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN: SAME PERFORMANCE OUTCOME BUT DIFFERENT DESIGN SOLUTIONS

A Review on Numerical Approach to Achieve Building Energy Efficiency for Energy, Economy and Environment (3E) Benefit

Linking BIM and Design of Experiments to balance architectural and technical design factors for energy performance

Use of whole building simulation in on-line performance assessment: Modeling and implementation issues

Towards occupant-centric simulation-aided building design: a case study

BPOpt: A framework for BIM-based performance optimization

Occupant Behavior Modeling for Building Performance Simulation: Review of the Recent Advances and Research Trends

Building Information Modelling (BIM) and Energy Performance of Building - A Review

Supporting Early-Stage Design Decisions with Building Performance Optimisation: Findings from a Design Experiment

State-of-the-art review of occupant behavior modeling and implementation in building performance simulation

A Radical Shift to Probabilistic Thinking: Integrating Energy Analysis in Performance-Driven Building Morphology Generation

Building Automation and Control Systems and performance optimization: A framework for analysis

The impact of occupants’ behaviours on building energy analysis: A research review

Integrating simulation into design: an experiment in pedagogical environments

A review on simulation based multi-objective optimization of space layout design parameters on building energy performance