Abstract:School choice initiatives–which empower parents to choose which schools their children attend–are built on the assumptions that parents know what features of a school are most important to their family and that they are capable of focusing on the most important features when they make their decisions. However, decades of psychological research suggest that decision makers lack metacognitive knowledge of the factors that influence their decisions. We sought to reconcile this discrepancy between the policy assumptions and the psychological research. To do so, we asked participants to complete Choice-Based Conjoint surveys in which they made series of choices between different hypothetical schools. We then asked participants to self-report the weight they placed on each attribute when making their choices. Across four studies, we found that participants did not know how much weight they had placed on various school attributes. Average correlations between stated and revealed weights ranged from r = .34–.54. Stated weights predicted different choices than revealed weights in 16.41–20.63% of decisions. These metacognitive limitations persisted regardless of whether the participants were parents or non-parents (Study 1a/1b), the nature of the attributes that participants used to evaluate alternatives (Study 2), and whether or not decision makers had access to school ratings that could be used as metacognitive aids (Study 3). In line with prior psychological research–and in contract to policy assumptions–these findings demonstrate that decision makers do not have particularly strong metacognitive knowledge of the factors that influence their school choice decisions. As a result, parents making school choice decisions are likely to seek out and use the wrong information, thus leading to suboptimal school choices. Future research should replicate these results in more ecologically valid samples and test new approaches to school choice that account for these metacognitive limitations.

Who Convinces Whom? Parent and Child Perceptions of Children's Engagement in Parental Purchase Decisions

Children’s influence on parental purchase decisions: Scale development and validation

Parent‐child decision making in children’s clothing stores

Parental Assessment of Benefits and of Dangers Determines Children's Permission to Play Outdoors

Is it all due to peers? The influence of peers on children's snack purchase decisions

Investigating the Factors Influencing Parent Toy Purchase Decisions: Reasoning and Consequences

It takes two: the effect of child characteristics on U.S. parents’ motivations for allowing electronic media use

Parental rights or parental wrongs: Parents’ metacognitive knowledge of the factors that influence their school choice decisions

Children's Responses to Advertising in Social Games

Parents’ Responses to Child-Targeted Influencer Advertising: An Investigation Using the Persuasion Knowledge Model

The Need to Distinguish Between Quantity and Quality in Research on Parental Involvement: The Example of Parental Help With Homework

Overparenting in Parents of Elementary School Children: The Direct Association with Positive Parent-Child Relationship and the Indirect Associations with Parental Self-Efficacy and Psychological Well-Being

The Influence of Parent Behaviors on Positive Illusory Bias in Children With ADHD

Strategies elementary school children use to influence mothers' food purchasing decisions

Children's perception of food marketing across digital media platforms.

'My Mom Got Influenced by Yours': The persuasiveness of mom influencers in relation to mothers' food assessments and decisions

Parental Involvement and the Intergenerational Transmission of Economic Preferences, Attitudes and Personality Traits

Overparenting and Homework: The Student's Task, But Everyone's Responsibility

Parents’ perception or children’s perception? Parental involvement and student engagement in Chinese middle schools

The apple does not fall far: stable predictive relationships between parents' ratings of their own and their children's self-regulatory abilities

EXPRESS: Developing Strengths or Remedying Weaknesses? How Perceived Social Mobility Affects Parents’ Purchase Preferences for Children’s Educational Products