Transfer Pricing the Cloud: Tax Characterization of International Trade of Digital Goods and Services between Related Parties
Sterling Jones
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2460138
2014-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Informational Technology (IT) services today form a core component of most multinational enterprises in their mission to deliver goods and services and realize a profit. Cloud computing is the newest mechanism to deliver IT goods and services. Given this new global market place, international taxation systems have not grown as fast the economy. These conditions create opportunities for Multinational Enterprises (MNE) to structure their operations, particularly IT and cloud computing, in a way to minimize their tax burdens through location in low or no tax jurisdictions. This results in a diminution in tax revenue, or base erosion, and is the consequence of intangibles being shifted to no or low tax jurisdictions with the corresponding income they generate, being attributed to those jurisdictions and taxed accordingly under existing frameworks. As a result, there exist gaps within this international framework that lead to low or no taxation and stranded cash offshore. The OECD coined the term Base Erosion Profit Shifting, or BEPS, to describe this issue. Cloud computing is the most recent iteration of base erosion and profit-shifting that is facing multinational enterprises and taxing sovereigns. BEPS is the taxation practice of shifting income to alternate low or no tax jurisdictions. MNEs accomplish this by shifting intangible items that generate income, such as royalties, rentals, and leases, to entities in jurisdictions that levy low or no tax. The resulting diminution in the home country’s tax revenue base generated enough concern amongst the G-20 that they petitioned the OECD to address BEPS and prepare an Action Plan. The resulting action plan addresses BEPS in a broad fashion, however, for purposes of this paper, it will focus on BEPS as it pertains to Cloud Computing to highlight some of the major issues facing MNEs, law firms, accountants, and taxing sovereigns.