Abstract:Background: Some authors consider the ultimate purpose of Assessment for Learning to be the promotion of pupils’ autonomy. But the concept of autonomy is problematic and teachers’ attempts to promote autonomy in the classroom can seem both vague and impractical. Purpose: In this paper, following Ecclestone (2002), I suggest that a full definition of autonomy includes children’s independence, proactivity and critical inquiry in the classroom – which by their nature centre around the individual’s capacity for self-directed learning and meta-learning in their lives. I illustrate how one teacher promoted all three aspects of autonomy through her classroom feedback. Feedback is conceptualised as all the comments made by the teacher as a reaction to any activity or behaviour by pupils. Design and methods: These examples draw on research data collected in 2009–11 in which nine ‘profile’ Year 5 (aged 9–10) children and their teacher were observed and interviewed about teacher feedback and ways in which it might promote autonomy. Five lessons across six months during 2010, which were video-taped, audio-recorded, observed and followed up by interviews with individuals, pairs or threes from among the nine profile children, have been analysed in detail. Findings: Findings from this detailed analysis of lesson and interview transcripts suggested that the teacher employed a range of skilfully crafted autonomy-promoting feedback. Categories for this feedback consisted of the teacher feedback during the five lessons encouraging the pupil’s: independence, usually in the sense of the child cultivating a view that might stand out from the general view (23 instances observed); proactivity in learning, manifested through that child’s unsolicited engagement with a topic (80 occasions noted); metasocial critical inquiry, which was subdivided into: firstly, metasocial critical inquiry into rules about life including assessment (60 instances); and secondly, metasocial critical inquiry into relationships, including social relationships occurring during learning collaboration (27 occasions); and finally, most frequently, critical inquiry into learning processes (94 examples noted). Conclusions: I conclude by noting that the teacher’s feedback – whether intentionally or not – had the potential to inspire children’s immediate and longer-term developments in independent learning, proactivity and critical inquiry.

A qualitative study of primary teachers’ classroom feedback rationales

A categorisation of teacher feedback in the classroom: a field study on feedback based on routine classroom assessment in primary school

Roles, relationships and emotions: Student teachers’ understanding of feedback as interpersonal

Teachers’ experiences of student feedback: A view from a department of social work in Sweden

Feedback as a relational concept in the classroom

Inquiring into children’s experiences of teacher feedback: reconceptualising Assessment for Learning

Student teachers’ perceptions of feedback as an aid to reflection for developing effective practice in the classroom

ESL Teachers’ Perceptions of Effective Classroom Assessment Feedback

Analyzing Teachers' Feedback Practices in Response to Students' Work in Science Classrooms

Exploring teacher perceptions of different types of ‘feedback practices’ in higher education: implications for teacher feedback literacy

Making learning effective – quantity and quality of pre-service teachers’ feedback

Changes in Student Motivation and Teacher Decision Making When Implementing a Formative Assessment Practice

The practice of promoting primary pupils’ autonomy: examples of teacher feedback

Supporting Peer Feedback on Learning Strategies: Effects on Self-Efficacy and Feedback Quality

Student feedback as a predictor of learning motivation, academic achievement and classroom climate

Teachers' Feedback on Oral Reading: A Critical Review of its Effects and the use of Theory in Research

Classroom Talk: The Ubiquity of Feedback

Effects of student feedback as a method of self-evaluating the quality of teaching

Trainee teachers’ experiences of classroom feedback practices and their motivation to learn

An Investigation of Feedback Strategies Used by Science Teachers in the Classroom Setting: A Mixed-Methods Research

What do you think of when you hear the word ‘feedback’? A reflective thematic analysis study of interviews