Abstract:Background: Assembly algorithm choice should be a deliberate, well-justified decision when researchers create genome assemblies for eukaryotic organisms from third-generation sequencing technologies. While third-generation sequencing by Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) and Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) has overcome the disadvantages of short read lengths specific to next-generation sequencing (NGS), third-generation sequencers are known to produce more error-prone reads, thereby generating a new set of challenges for assembly algorithms and pipelines. However, the introduction of HiFi reads, which offer substantially reduced error rates, has provided a promising solution for more accurate assembly outcomes. Since the introduction of third-generation sequencing technologies, many tools have been developed that aim to take advantage of the longer reads, and researchers need to choose the correct assembler for their projects. Results: We benchmarked state-of-the-art long-read de novo assemblers to help readers make a balanced choice for the assembly of eukaryotes. To this end, we used 12 real and 64 simulated datasets from different eukaryotic genomes, with different read length distributions, imitating PacBio continuous long-read (CLR), PacBio high-fidelity (HiFi), and ONT sequencing to evaluate the assemblers. We include 5 commonly used long-read assemblers in our benchmark: Canu, Flye, Miniasm, Raven, and wtdbg2 for ONT and PacBio CLR reads. For PacBio HiFi reads , we include 5 state-of-the-art HiFi assemblers: HiCanu, Flye, Hifiasm, LJA, and MBG. Evaluation categories address the following metrics: reference-based metrics, assembly statistics, misassembly count, BUSCO completeness, runtime, and RAM usage. Additionally, we investigated the effect of increased read length on the quality of the assemblies and report that read length can, but does not always, positively impact assembly quality. Conclusions: Our benchmark concludes that there is no assembler that performs the best in all the evaluation categories. However, our results show that overall Flye is the best-performing assembler for PacBio CLR and ONT reads, both on real and simulated data. Meanwhile, best-performing PacBio HiFi assemblers are Hifiasm and LJA. Next, the benchmarking using longer reads shows that the increased read length improves assembly quality, but the extent to which that can be achieved depends on the size and complexity of the reference genome.

Versatile genome assembly evaluation with QUAST-LG

Benchmarking genome assembly methods on metagenomic sequencing data

Benchmarking of bioinformatics tools for the hybrid de novo assembly of human whole-genome sequencing data

GenomeQC: a quality assessment tool for genome assemblies and gene structure annotations

Benchmarking multi-platform sequencing technologies for human genome assembly

Benchmarking of next and third generation sequencing technologies and their associated algorithms for de novo genome assembly

Comparison of the Two Up-to-date Sequencing Technologies for Genome Assembly: HiFi Reads of Pacific Biosciences Sequel II System and Ultralong Reads of Oxford Nanopore

Benchmarking de novo assembly methods on metagenomic sequencing data

Exploring Genome Characteristics and Sequence Quality Without a Reference

Benchmarking of Long-Read Sequencing, Assemblers and Polishers for Yeast Genome

Genome sequence assembly evaluation using long-range sequencing data

Comprehensive assessment of 11 de novo HiFi assemblers on complex eukaryotic genomes and metagenomes

Assemblathon 2: evaluating de novo methods of genome assembly in three vertebrate species

Identifying the Causes and Consequences of Assembly Gaps Using a Multiplatform Genome Assembly of a Bird-of-paradise.

A5-miseq: an updated pipeline to assemble microbial genomes from Illumina MiSeq data

A survey on computational strategies for genome-resolved gut metagenomics

Evaluating long-read de novo assembly tools for eukaryotic genomes: insights and considerations

Comprehensive Evaluation of Genome Gap-Filling Tools Utilizing Long Reads

Efficient High-Quality Metagenome Assembly from Long Accurate Reads using Minimizer-space de Bruijn Graphs

User-friendly genome assembly and gene annotation pipelines for vertebrates

Easing genomic surveillance: A comprehensive performance evaluation of long-read assemblers across multi-strain mixture data of HIV-1 and Other pathogenic viruses for constructing a user-friendly bioinformatic pipeline