Abstract:Soil organic carbon (SOC) losses under a changing climate are driven by the temperature sensitivity of SOC mineralization (usually expressed as Q10, the multiplier of activity with 10 &#176;C temperature increase). The activation energy theory (AET) suggests that, due to higher activation energies, the more complex the carbon, the higher is mineralization Q10. However, studies on Q10 have been inconsistent with regard to AET. Measurements of potential soil enzymes activity Q10 even contradicted AET: Phenoloxidase (representing complex carbon) had consistently lower Q10 than the more labile xylanase and glucosidase. This study used two approaches of examining Q10 in SOC modeling: 1) Bayesian calibration (BC) and 2) using different measured enzyme Q10 as proxies for mineralization Q10 of different SOC pools. The SOC model was DAISY (S. Hansen et al., 2012). BC informed Q10 by field measured data, while the second approach tested if directly using enzyme Q10 (of phenoloxidase, glucosidase and xylanase) for DAISY pools improved simulation results. Both approaches used the temperature sensitive measurements of CO2 evolution and soil microbial biomass. The measured enzyme Q10 were from field manipulation experiments with bare fallow and vegetated plots in the two regions of Kraichgau and Swabian Jura in Southwest Germany. The enzyme-derived Q10 were used for modelling those fields and furthermore for in&#8209;situ litterbag decomposition experiments at 20 sites in the same region. Two further laboratory experiments with temperature manipulation were included: an incubation of the field residues into soil and an incubation of bare soil from the start and year 50 of a long duration bare fallow (from Ultuna). The BC made use of CO2 and microbial data to inform about the range of Q10 of different carbon pools for the individual experiments and combined data.The BC of the residue incubation experiment constrained Q10 for metabolic (~3) and structural litter (~2). Estimated 95% credibility intervals did not overlap. The BC for Ultuna could constrain the slow and fast SOC pool with Q10 ~2.8 and ~3, respectively, but credibility intervals of both pools overlapped. The Q10 of field experiments, which had most abundant data, could not be constrained by BC, probably because their annual temparature variability was too low. However, the model errors of the field experiment could be reduced by the second approach, when the Q10 of phenoloxidase was used for to the structural litter pool as well as for the fast and slow SOC pools. Thus regional enzyme Q10 improved the model fit but only for regional simulations. Therefore, they could be useful proxies when natural temperature range is too small to inform temperature sensitivity by BC. Any trends found in this study contradicted AET, both from measured enzymes and BC of the incubation experiments. This calls for alternative Q10 hypotheses and the need for individual Q10 values for different SOC pool rather than a general one. BC approaches would benefit from a wider temperature range of field experiments and understanding what causes variable enzyme Q10 could help to improve future SOC models.

Catalytic power of enzymes decreases with temperature: New insights for understanding soil C cycling and microbial ecology under warming

Global Meta-Analysis on the Responses of Soil Extracellular Enzyme Activities to Warming

Enzymic moderations of bacterial and fungal communities on short- and long-term warming impacts on soil organic carbon

Soil carbon loss with warming: New evidence from carbon‐degrading enzymes

Restricted power: Can microorganisms maintain soil organic matter stability under warming exceeding 2 degrees?

Increasing microbial carbon use efficiency with warming predicts soil heterotrophic respiration globally

Season, but not experimental warming, affects the activity and temperature sensitivity of extracellular enzymes

Differential temperature sensitivity of intracellular metabolic processes and extracellular soil enzyme activities

Differential responses of carbon‐degrading enzyme activities to warming: Implications for soil respiration

No Temperature Acclimation of Soil Extracellular Enzymes to Experimental Warming in an Alpine Grassland Ecosystem on the Tibetan Plateau

Enhanced Decomposition of Stable Soil Organic Carbon and Microbial Catabolic Potentials by Long-Term Field Warming

Soil enzyme kinetics and thermodynamics in response to long-term vegetation succession

Reduced carbon use efficiency and increased microbial turnover with soil warming

Microbial temperature sensitivity and biomass change explain soil carbon loss with warming

Linking temperature sensitivities of soil enzymes to temperature responses of different organic matter pools in the DAISY model

Soil microbial community responses to a decade of warming as revealed by comparative metagenomics.

Warming Enhances Old Organic Carbon Decomposition Through Altering Functional Microbial Communities.

Meta-analysis of Experimental Warming on Soil Invertase and Urease Activities

Warming increases the relative change in the turnover rate of decadally cycling soil carbon in microbial biomass carbon and soil respiration

Responses of soil microbial carbon use efficiency to warming: Review and prospects

Changes in soil microbial activity and their linkages with soil carbon under global warming