Compositionality and the Prospect of a Pluralistic Semantic Theory

Adam C. Podlaskowski
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00048402.2018.1456554
2018-04-26
Australasian Journal of Philosophy
Abstract:A semantic theory is committed to semantic monism just in case every particular semantic property posited by the theory is a member of the same kind. The commitment to semantic monism appears to draw some support from the need to provide a compositional semantics, since taking a single kind of semantic property as key to a semantic theory affords a uniform pattern on the basis of which the meaning of any given sentence can be compositionally determined. This line of support highlights a tension between the principle of compositionality and taking a more pluralistic approach to semantic theorizing. In this essay, that tension is relieved, leaving open the prospect of a pluralistic semantic theory that observes the principle of compositionality.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?