Abstract:The analysis of morphology is crucial to the study of phylogeny in many ancient and modern organismal groups. Recently a number of arguments have been made in favor of regarding certain kinds of morphometric variables as putatively homologous characters and allowing them to participate, along with other non-morphometric variables, in parsimony-based cladistic analyses. These arguments rest on the assumptions that geometric landmarks incorporate the concept of biological homology and that partial warp and principal warp morphometric variables uniquely incorporate and operationalize the concept of spatial localization, thus providing investigators with the ability to assess patterns and directions of geometrical variation in unmeasured regions of organic forms. Literature review, coupled with empirical investigations of similarities and differences among three different morphometric data analysis methods on two different datasets suggest that there is no support for these assertions. Geometric landmarks, which form the basis for all morphometric measurements and latent shape variables, have no necessary correspondence to biological homology. Partial warp variables, coordinate-point eigenshape variables, and inter-landmark distance-based singular vector shape-change variables all express localized (= regionally-weighted) geometric deformations. However, none of these deformation patterns are localized in the sense of being truly independent from globally-distributed aspects of shape change. All three of the morphometric data analysis methods investigated are capable of inferring patterns of shape change in remote regions of the form so long as a spatially adequate array of landmarks is used as the basis for the shape analysis. Based on these results it is concluded that: (1) all types of morphometric procedures are potentially useful in phylogenetic inference to the extent that they are able to summarize patterns of biotic shape change within the Euclidean space of the original measurements; (2) morphometric interpretations are strengthened by using alternative analytic approaches to probe the geometric system in a hypothetico-deductive manner and achieve a robust and consistent interpretation of underlying differences among operational taxonomic units (OTU s); and (3) while deformation- based morphometric variables can be used to analyze the distribution of organic shapes in a variety of measurement and latent variable spaces, they represent abstract investigative tools that are tied irreducibly to particular samples and data. Such variables can be used to study morphological characters, refine character and character state definitions, and aid in the assignment of character states to OTU s. However, they are not characters themselves and may not be suitable for phylogenetic analyses directly. In addition, a new morphometric data analysis technique coordinate-point eigenshape analysis is described and its use illustrated.

Topological Data Analysis as a Morphometric Method: Using Persistent Homology to Demarcate a Leaf Morphospace

Morphological Plant Modeling: Unleashing Geometric and Topological Potential Within the Plant Sciences

Reshaping Plant Biology: Qualitative and Quantitative Descriptors for Plant Morphology

3D Morphological Analysis of Arabidopsis Sepals.

Topological data analysis reveals core heteroblastic and ontogenetic programs embedded in leaves of grapevine (Vitaceae) and maracuyá (Passifloraceae)

Topological data analysis reveals a core gene expression backbone that defines form and function across flowering plants

Geometric and topological approaches to shape variation in Ginkgo leaves

Topological phenotypes constitute a new dimension in the phenotypic space of leaf venation networks

Intra‐leaf modeling of Cannabis leaflet shape produces leaf models that predict genetic and developmental identities

Morphological Analysis of Size and Shape (MASS): An integrative software program for morphometric analyses of leaves

3D Morphological Feature Quantification and Analysis of Corn Leaves

Novel definition and quantitative analysis of branch structure with topological data analysis

Computational Topology and Its Applications in Geometric Design

Topological data analysis expands the genotype to phenotype map for 3D maize root system architecture

From leaves to labels: Building modular machine learning networks for rapid herbarium specimen analysis with LeafMachine2

LANDMARKS, LOCALIZATION AND THE USE OF MORPHOMETRICS IN PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS

Dynamic shape analysis and comparison of leaf growth

Multi-level description of leaf index based on analysis of canopy structure

Advanced Active Shape Model Applications of Classifying Plant Leaves

Relational persistent homology for multispecies data with application to the tumor microenvironment

On topological data analysis for SHM; an introduction to persistent homology