Abstract:Despite research showing that perceptually fluent stimuli (i.e., stimuli that are easier to process) are given higher judgment of learning (JOL) ratings than perceptually disfluent stimuli, it remains unknown whether the influence of perceptual fluency on JOLs is driven by the fluent or disfluent items. Moreover, it is unclear whether this difference hinges on relative differences in fluency. The current study addressed these unanswered questions by employing (Fiacconi et al., Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 46:926–944, 2020), Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 46 [5], 926–944) letter set priming procedure. In this procedure, participants are first exposed to words containing only a subset of letters. Following this exposure, JOLs to new words composed of the same letters (i.e., fluent), and new words composed of nonexposed letters (i.e., disfluent) are compared with isolate the contribution of perceptual fluency. Because this procedure does not rely on parametric variations in perceptual features, we can directly assess the potential benefit and/or cost of fluent and disfluent items, respectively, by including neutral baseline conditions. Moreover, implementing both a mixed- and pure-list design allowed us to assess the comparative nature of perceptual fluency on JOLs. Counter to previous assumptions, our results are the first to demonstrate that perceptual disfluency decreases JOLs. Moreover, we found that the influence of perceptual disfluency on JOLs hinges on the relative differences in fluency between items even in the absence of a belief about the mnemonic impact of the fluency manipulation. These findings have important implications as they provide evidence that the difficulty, rather than ease, of information form the basis of individuals metacognitive judgments.

Can very small font size enhance memory?

Association and dissociation between judgments of learning and memory: A Meta-analysis of the font size effect

The perceived importance of words in large font guides learning and selective memory

Perceptually fluent features of study words do not inflate judgements of learning: evidence from font size, highlights, and Sans Forgetica font type

The effect of emotional valence and font size on metacognition and memory

The font size effect depends on inter-item relation

How font size affects judgments of learning: Simultaneous mediating effect of item-specific beliefs about fluency and moderating effect of beliefs about font size and memory

How Much Do Metamemory Beliefs Contribute to the Font-Size Effect in Judgments of Learning?

The Influence of Visual Mental Imagery Size on Metamemory Accuracy in Judgment of Learning.

Exploring fonts as retrieval cues in text-based learning

The contribution of metamemory beliefs to the font size effect on judgments of learning: Is word frequency a moderating factor?

The Effect of Font Size on Reading Comprehension on Second and Fifth Grade Children: Bigger Is Not Always Better

Influence of Cue Word Perceptual Information on Metamemory Accuracy in Judgement of Learning

Interplay Between the Object and Its Symbol: the Size-Congruency Effect

Higher-contrast images are better remembered during naturalistic encoding

Attention focused on memory: The episodic flanker effect with letters, words, colors, and pictures

Long-Term Memory: Scaling of Information to Brain Size

Font Size Modulates Saccade-Target Selection in Chinese Reading

I remember it now, so I'll remember it later: Working memory strength guides predictions for long-term memory performance

When remembering less is more: Unfiltered items are associated with reduced memory fidelity in visual short-term memory

Probing the effect of perceptual (dis)fluency on metacognitive judgments