Aesthetic and metaphysical meaning in Lomazzo's writings on painting

Claire Lapraik Guest

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5617/acta.5737

Acta ad archaeologiam et artium historiam pertinentia

Abstract:No abstract

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Painting and Ontology: D. H. Lawrence as an Art Historian

Milovan Novaković

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3986/pkn.v46.i2.03

2023-06-24

Primerjalna književnost

Abstract:More than any other twentieth-century writer, D. H. Lawrence developed a profound understanding of painting and evaluated this art form through the prism of his idiosyncratic ontological scheme. In allegiance to his polaristic philosophy, in which everything is created by the opposition of static and dynamic, mind and body, optical and tactile, “Will-to-Motion” and “Will-to- Inertia,” light and darkness, Lawrence conceived the history of visual arts as a mirror of this universal opposition of ultimate metaphysical forces. Despite his general view that Western art was entirely under the dominion of idea, mind, and light, Lawrence pointed to several examples in which dark, bodily, and haptic experiences were processed pictorially. This essay intends to introduce Lawrence as an art historian who understood works of art and art historical periods as constituted out of a never-ending power struggle between the corporeal and the spiritual, and who always sought and called for their reconciliation and balance in his literature.
Questioning Cézanne across Sightlines: Balzac, Zola, and Merleau-Ponty

Véronique M. Fóti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/h11020056

2022-04-14

Humanities

Abstract:Although Merleau-Ponty’s privileging of Cézanne in the context of his philosophy of painting does not explicitly address the painter’s relation to literature, this relation is important and somewhat problematic. Cézanne was an avid reader of both classical Latin and contemporary French literature, but he sought, in his maturity, to dissociate painting from the inspiration of literature. The danger of a mode of figurative painting informed by literature is explored in Balzac’s novella The Unknown Masterpiece, of which there are echoes in Merleau-Ponty’s discussions of painting, and which is alluded to in Emile Zola’s novel The Masterpiece, which led Cézanne to break off his lifelong friendship with the author. Zola’s novel contradicts Merleau-Ponty’s emphasis on the artist’s creative freedom by portraying his protagonist, modeled on Cézanne, as destroyed by a fatality of destiny. Cézanne, in his maturity, sought to conjoin in painting a “logic of the eyes” with a “logic of the brain” resulting in an art genuinely “parallel with nature”, which it sought to express rather than to represent. The article explores this dissociation of painting from literature and autonomy with respect to what Merleau-Ponty calls “the dimension of color” and to Cézanne’s lifelong theme of bathers in a landscape.
ASK ME! A Visit to the Rijksmuseum or the Analyst As a Painter

Giuseppe Civitarese

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07351690.2024.2345577

2024-07-25

Psychoanalytic Inquiry

Abstract:The article is actually made up of a series of digressions representing the author's unique approach to engaging with J. Palmer's ideas and offering a response. Instead of constituting a formal discussion, they have evolved into marginal notes inspired by an occasional visit to Amsterdam's Rijksmuseum, which is world famous for the masterpieces it houses. This formula allows for the exploration of various issues related to representation in art and life, as inherently intersubjective. The problems of aesthetic experience overlap with those of psychoanalysis, and vice versa: themes such as distance and aura; the relationship between content and container, i.e., between form and content or between frame and artistic motif; the aesthetics of the sublime as a portrayal of the vicissitudes of the primary relationship with the object; the negative of the invisible as what enables vision; art as a thematization of intersubjectivity; the artistic gesture as the movement and expression of the body, or rather, of intercorporeality; the construction of meaning that occurs in the "carnal" intimacy with art; painting as meditation on perception as unconscious (Merleau-Ponty); the pictorial structure of the dream within the dream or mise en abîme: these are all themes touched upon in a fragmented manner but that refer to various other works in which the author has addressed them, giving the sense of an ongoing research endeavor, where what matters is not the destination but the process of traversing the path of art as access to the psyche. All are interwoven in a series of internal references, the final figure or figures of which are left substantially open. The importance of reflection on art in general is continually reaffirmed in the work, both explicitly and implicitly, in the lines and between the lines.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Science, Art and Geometrical Imagination

J. -P. Luminet,J.-P. Luminet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0911.0267

2009-11-02

Popular Physics

Abstract:From the geocentric, closed world model of Antiquity to the wraparound universe models of relativistic cosmology, the parallel history of space representations in science and art illustrates the fundamental role of geometric imagination in innovative findings. Through the analysis of works of various artists and scientists like Plato, Durer, Kepler, Escher, Grisey or the present author, it is shown how the process of creation in science and in the arts rests on aesthetical principles such as symmetry, regular polyhedra, laws of harmonic proportion, tessellations, group theory, etc., as well as beauty, conciseness and emotional approach of the world.
Remembrances of Paul Locher

Anjan Chatterjee,Helmut Leder,Marcos Nadal,Jeff Smith,Lisa Smith,Pablo P. L. Tinio,Oshin Vartanian,Debra Zellner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/02762374241288340

IF: 1.675

2024-10-15

Empirical Studies of the Arts

Abstract:Empirical Studies of the Arts, Ahead of Print. Paul Locher passed away on 20 August 2024. Paul was an outstanding scientist and a central figure in the field of empirical aesthetics. He made important contributions to numerous areas including the study of symmetry, balance, facial attractiveness, museum behaviour, artwork composition and restoration, and aesthetics of food, but in particular to the study of eye movements in aesthetic appreciation of artworks. Indeed, his research on eye tracking is a touchstone for visual perception in empirical aesthetics. Here, a group of Paul's colleagues remember and celebrate him through a set of recollections that honour how he shaped their research and lives. It is hoped that this will offer a glimpse into the wonderful scholar and human being that Paul was, and why he will be sorely missed.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Loss and beauty: how experts and novices judge paintings with lacunae

Mariella Pazzaglia,Giulia Galli,Erik Leemhuis,Anna Maria Giannini,Tiziana Pascucci,Eliana Billi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00426-020-01370-9

2020-06-06

Psychological Research

Abstract:<p class="a-plus-plus">Lacunae are the voids left by missing or damaged pieces of artwork, and their presence constitutes a central problem in the aesthetic experience of viewing artwork. However, we hypothesize that experience and knowledge of art might differentially modify viewer reactions to degraded artwork. Here, we investigated the implicit and explicit attitudes of art experts and non-experts towards the aesthetics of perfectly intact and lacunar artwork. Sections of Flemish oil paintings were displayed with or without a degradation mask, which mimics lacunae. Three groups differing in their interaction with art were assessed: art restorers, art historians, and art viewers lacking any art-related professional expertise. We found that (1) professional experience/expertise in art restoration affected implicit, but not explicit, attitudes among restorers, (2) art historians had positive explicit, but not implicit, attitudes toward intact artwork, and (3) it was difficult for non-specialist viewers to understand or appreciate artwork that was not perfectly intact. We further discuss the implications of these results to other forms of aesthetic evaluation and expertise. Modified preferences in experts may improve knowledge of the plastic changes that occur in the cognition of aesthetics and may thus be of significant relevance to enhance the effectiveness of art conservation programs.</p>
For an aesthetics of ambiance

Jean-François Augoyard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/ambiances.3136

2020-10-13

Ambiances

Abstract:Why an aesthetics of ambiances? The answer to this question if far from being solely theoretical. It is associated with my personal career in research and academic teaching since the 1980s.On the one hand, observing everyday ethos, through walks, landscape sensitivity, sound practices, the reception of architecture and street arts have revealed the ambiance as an essential way to question the substance of what is unseen, the nature of the background to the lived environment.On the other hand, throughout my classes and aesthetics seminars in urban planning and architecture, “art’s place” in professions dominated by function forced me to rethink aesthetics as freed from its artistic imperative and digging into its more universal sensitive and atmospheric foundations.This paper reviews an aesthetics of ambiances that is currently being built, working on four levels. At the aesthetic level: what is the imperceptible? What role do non-visible forms play? At the epistemic level: how do we integrate the relevant knowledge that is still too exclusive? At the rhetorical level: how do the components of an ambiance organise themselves, and how can we name the configurations? At the level of aesthetic competence: who makes an ambiance? How are creation and reception divided?
About the work of Albert Lautman

Bernard Teissier

2023-11-17

Abstract:Some reflections on the role in the development of Mathematics of our unconscious perception of the world and just as unconscious organizing pulsions for those perceptions.

History and Overview
â€œIN PROIEZIONEâ€: SPAZIO E IMMAGINE IN LAS MENINAS DI DIEGO VELÃZQUEZ

Luigi Cocchiarella

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4081/scie.2016.634

2020-03-10

Abstract:This study focuses on the spatial analysis of Las Meninas, the worldwide well-known pictorial art masterpiece by Diego VelÃ¡zquez. Aesthetics, form, and symbolism, are here interlinked with a geometric pattern dependent on the exact location of the designated viewpoint, which severely obeys to the projective rules of linear perspective, where, as a gem in the gem, even the image of a mirror appears, to masterly highlight the final moral of the story, surprisingly explicated by the appeal to reflection. Sophisticated geometry feature and sublime graphic execution work together in this painting to establish the role of pictorial art as a creative besides imitative activity, representing painting itself in the very act of setting a pictorial reality, all this at the height of the so-called Golden Age of the Spanish art.
Stage Props, Distorting Mirrors, and the Aesthetics of Incompletion: Metafictional Turns in Pierre and Mardi

Giacomo Traina

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/lvn.2024.a925510

2024-03-01

Leviathan

Abstract:Abstract: Save for his letters and the review/essay “Hawthorne and His Mosses,” Herman Melville left behind no manifesto. He all but entrusted the principles of his ars poetica to characters and narrators. His body of work is rife with speakers questioning the possibilities of craft. It is as if Melville would split himself into a host of voices and personae, entrusting projections of himself with the task of judging others. This article deals with two of such occurrences: 1) Pierre ’s chapters on Pierre-as-writer, in which we see an artist-figure (the narrator) chronicling the failure of another (Pierre); 2) Mardi ’s Chapter 180, in which a philosopher (Babbalanja) narrates the deeds of a poet (Lombardo). In both instances, Melville presents the reader with a book-within-the-book whose plot details are kept deliberately vague. Both Pierre’s manuscript and Lombardo’s national epic, the Koztanza , are described only in the most general of ways. They are not two texts-within-the-text as much as two stage props charged with ritual significance but left without any real content. This article argues that Melville intentionally withholds information from the reader regarding these fictive oeuvres . Pierre ’s and Mardi ’s plot-absences thus become textual mirrors reflecting changing attitudes towards the creative process during two distinct stages of Melville’s career.
From the aesthetic mind to the human cultures: Towards an anthropology of aesthetics

Lorenzo Bartalesi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13128/AISTHESIS-25618

2019-06-17

Abstract:This paper aims to shed light on the links between aesthetic mind and cultural dynamics. We’ll begin by describing the behavioural, cognitive and phenomenological complexity of the aesthetic before examining the role of such multidimensional phenomenon in the processes of cultural transmission. This analysis will lead us to consider aesthetics as a key frame of reference indispensable for investigating the creative and freely productive character of the processes through which individuals reproduce and transform their culture.

Art,Psychology,Sociology,Philosophy
Toward a Post-critical Literary Theory

Jean Bocharova,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/traddisc20194512

2019-01-01

Tradition and Discovery: The Polanyi Society Periodical

Abstract:This essay examines Meaning as Polanyi’s statement on aesthetics. The core of his aesthetic theory emphasizes the power of art to move the imagination. I examine metaphors he uses for this kind of movement—descent along a gradient, indwelling, and transcendence—and suggest implications for literary study.

English Else
[Abstract painting, a mental esthetic construction without exact correspondence with reality (José Guerrero: manuel and corporal expressions in his paintings)]

Alberto Portera Sánchez

Abstract:It is desirable that a truthful aesthetic experience should be the consequence of a complete observation detached from all sorts of commercial, social, political or cultural ties. If during this period of admiration of a work of art a personal concentration is reached, the admirer perceives a liberation from all sorts of limiting ties and a rewarding artistic feeling. A similar type of mental freedom must be reached by the artist and prevail during the process of creation which must reach its greatest dimension in abstract paintings because not being illustrations they demand from the spectator a well developed habit to detect its esthetic values, difficult to perceive because they are in the abstract order. The dimensions such as perspective, symmetry, lights and shadows, usually integrated in figurative paintings to create well defined tridimensional spaces are not included in abstractions because this type of geometrical composition is not needed. In contemporary abstraction the design itself has lost its formal meaning and its protagonist role. It is frequently replaced by abrupt gestures as it is the case in the styles named "action painting" (Jackson Pollack) or "abstract expressionism" (Antonio Saura). Other abstract painters close to "minimalism" simply drop the colors on the canvas without any attempt to design but full of aesthetic energy and even single colors uniformly bathe the surface of the linen (Rothko). Other american artists of the sixties (Monis Louis) are also to be admired. They allow that the deposited and sliding colors themselves initiate and finish interesting artistic compositions. They become esential creative agents in the painting without being forced to be figurative nor to follow the creative will of the artist who, is simply acting as the first observer and only intervenes "a posteriori" accepting or rejecting the results. Only the colors and under the single influence of their sliding density create the shapes and artistic ensembles where there are still perceived their slow original movements. The observers of these abstract styles must initiate a process of perception without specific norms and wait until the engaging game of the colors generate emotional rewards in their minds such as amazement or interest that invite them to continue their tuning with the painting. If these artistic attraction is not evoked, the observer must be sadly satisfied with a simple ocular vision of the painting and again wait until the mental perception participates and the aesthetic reward is completed. What the "eyes of the mind" see is not a copy of the painting. A mental copy would not include the artistic meaning that the work of art contains which only emerges during the mental aesthetic encounter between the painting and the observer.
Contributions to the aesthetics of St. Augustine

Robert Warchał

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14746/h.2023.1.3

2023-03-31

Abstract:The following article aims to resolve the fundamental question referring to the way ideas exist in Augustine’s epistemology and also to familiarize the reader with contemporary interpretations of this issue. When framing his objectivist theory, Augustine drew on ancient traditions and the Bible, referring to deliberations on astronomy, cosmology and maths among others. In order for a work of art to be beautiful, it is necessary for human reason to perceive the right proportions in it, but their perfection does not depend solely on details and harmonious selection of parts, but also on something that links all these components to a mental idea. For Augustine, number is the principle of all things, but not in the sense of an arche, but in the sense of its presence in every being for example, the unity that the mind admires and of which it is itself an image. Its essence and meaning can only be found in God and therefore He is the first creator and greatest artist giving inspiration to all the arts. The thinker of Thagaste defined ideas as unalterable forms of things. In his view, all creation bears a certain trace of resemblance to God. That leads to a conclusion in the light of which every being is a greater or lesser implementation of the rules of res intelligibiles. The harmony of nature is of similar importance to him, as well as the beauty of the human body and mind. Facing the question of the ontological meaning of beauty author upholds its objectivity alongside other transcendental properties of being. Unity, equality, number, rhythm, proportion and order constitute the core elements of his aesthetics. The significance of Augustine’s doctrine lies in the fact that immaterial ideas enable achieving perfection in spiritual life, and hence bring us closer to the Creator.
Profundidad: el cuerpo y el color en Merleau-Ponty y Delaunay

F. Matti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46553/TAB.17.2021.P8-25

2021-06-01

Tábano

Abstract:This article aims to establish the relationship between the philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty and the artist Robert Delaunay regarding the corporeality and visibility of the work of art. These notions are developed by Maurice Merleau-Ponty in his text The eye and the spirit together with the theory of inobjective art of Robert Delaunay, expressed in From cubism to inobjective art . Moreover, Merleau-Ponty explicitly refers to Delaunay in this text, so it is possible to outline a correspondence between both, especially, regarding their aesthetic theories. The thesis that I will try to defend in this article is that the aesthetic developed by Merleau-Ponty is influenced by the writings of Delaunay. In order to accomplish this, I will try to showcase the similarities between both; such as the importance of colour, the profundity of Being expressed in painting or the corporeal and sensational reception and creation of the work of art.

Philosophy,Art
Art and the Reenchantment of Sensuous Human Activity

David Brubaker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-3234-5_9

2000-01-01

Abstract:Contemporary aestheticians face a question that has troubled writers since the Enlightenment: What is the role of the arts, when scientific rationalism and empirical understanding undermine our belief in the autonomy of each person? One reply consists of two familiar moves: the reiteration of dangerous effects caused by the hegemony of empirical thinking, and the affirmation that artworks serve as instruments for an emancipatory contact with some pre-objective domain. It is our challenging task to find an interpretation that upholds both of these moves, without linking aesthetic practices to the outmoded notion of a human subjectivity that is wholly disembodied, abstract and detached from actual life.
Towards an Aesthetic Epistemology of International Law

Sebastian Machado

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15718107-91030003

2022-08-19

Nordic Journal of International Law

Abstract:Abstract While there is a growing jurisprudence in the field of art (aesthetics) and international law, there is still space to theorise about the philosophical approach that we choose when we decide to engage the discipline as an artistic endeavour. In this article I argue that an aesthetic conception of international law can help go past the limitations imposed by rationalist accounts of legal order by thinking of it as an experience rather than a social science. This subjective shift in emphasis does not have to commit to a preordained theory of how international law is meant to look like, but rather focuses on the manner in which international lawyers engage with their discipline. I conclude by arguing that international law is not a naturally occurring phenomenon which exists in the empirical world and which we pick out by our senses – it is a human artefact constructed through our involvement with reality. This allows for many argumentative possibilities, and it is by the action of choosing these possibilities that we define the boundaries of what international law is .

English Else
Minor matters of major importance:1 On the vicissitudes of minor painting

John Chilver

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1386/jcp_00037_2

2022-04-06

Journal of Contemporary Painting

Abstract:This introductory editorial surveys a range of minor painting practices. It considers how minor painting might be defined, not in order to fix its designation, but to assess its implications, especially in relation to institutional authority, art’s historicity, art education and the authorial subject. There are discussions of Jim Shaw, Henry Darger, contributors to the current issue and others. These lead on to questions about art education. Rather than propose resolutions, the text instead traces the frictions between minor painting and institutional renderings of art education. The text emphasizes the ultimate inability of minor painting to escape or resist the institutional framing of painting. In reading Deleuze and Guattari’s Minor Literature book, the voice of community, rather than the individual subject, becomes important. Taking up the figure of community, the essay ends by placing the painter Norman Lewis in relation to a minor intervention within the milieu of Abstract Expressionism.
Embodied Perception and Harmonious Unity: Aesthetic Experience in Merleau-Ponty’s Theory of Painting and Chinese Song Dynasty Landscapes

Jia Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40647-016-0120-4

2016-02-10

Fudan Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences

Abstract:This paper explores embodied perception and its relation to aesthetic experience based on French phenomenologist Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s philosophy of painting. The discussion draws cases from both Western art, post-impressionist Paul Cezanne (1839–1906) and non-Western art, Chinese landscape paintings from the Northern Song Dynasty (960–1127). As I argue, their general vision for the primacy of embodiment in perception is similar; artists in both practices aim at a balance between representing visible forms of nature and interpreting their invisible, yet deeper meanings for human existence. Further, I will argue, a focus on Chinese aesthetic thought helps us recognize the aesthetics of moral existence and hence contributes significantly to self-cultivation. Influenced by Chinese philosophical traditions, Chinese landscape paintings, compared with Cezanne’s works, exemplify more strongly the indispensable role of the human body and indicate more explicitly a link between embodiment and moral ethics. The latter suggestion of the moral underpinnings in aesthetic perception and experience is particularly significant since Merleau-Ponty has not elaborated upon this point in any explicit manner.
The Influence of Laocius' Aesthetic Thoughts on Existing Forms of Ancient Chinese Paintings

Chang-qi LIU,Yu-yue CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3180.2015.03.015

2015-01-01

Abstract:As the founder of Taoism, Laocius' aesthetic thoughts have an endogenous meaning for Chinese classical aesthetics and art, which also fundamentally influence the existing forms of ancient Chinese paintings.Specifically, they create the spatial consciousness of "intergeneration of nihility and reality" and pursuit of"shapeless great forms" in terms of spatial morphology , generate the time sense of "taking the ancient time as the source" and artistic interest in "depositing the stale and bringing into the fresh" in terms of time morphology, affect the state pursuit of"stillness as the root, movement from stillness" in terms of situation creation, and establish the color taste of considering"the plain being beautiful, the colorful not valuable" in terms of color presentation.

Aesthetic and metaphysical meaning in Lomazzo's writings on painting

Painting and Ontology: D. H. Lawrence as an Art Historian

Questioning Cézanne across Sightlines: Balzac, Zola, and Merleau-Ponty

ASK ME! A Visit to the Rijksmuseum or the Analyst As a Painter

Science, Art and Geometrical Imagination

Remembrances of Paul Locher

Loss and beauty: how experts and novices judge paintings with lacunae

For an aesthetics of ambiance

About the work of Albert Lautman

â€œIN PROIEZIONEâ€: SPAZIO E IMMAGINE IN LAS MENINAS DI DIEGO VELÃZQUEZ

Stage Props, Distorting Mirrors, and the Aesthetics of Incompletion: Metafictional Turns in Pierre and Mardi

From the aesthetic mind to the human cultures: Towards an anthropology of aesthetics

Toward a Post-critical Literary Theory

[Abstract painting, a mental esthetic construction without exact correspondence with reality (José Guerrero: manuel and corporal expressions in his paintings)]

Contributions to the aesthetics of St. Augustine

Profundidad: el cuerpo y el color en Merleau-Ponty y Delaunay

Art and the Reenchantment of Sensuous Human Activity

Towards an Aesthetic Epistemology of International Law

Minor matters of major importance:1 On the vicissitudes of minor painting

Embodied Perception and Harmonious Unity: Aesthetic Experience in Merleau-Ponty’s Theory of Painting and Chinese Song Dynasty Landscapes

The Influence of Laocius' Aesthetic Thoughts on Existing Forms of Ancient Chinese Paintings

â€œIN PROIEZIONEâ€: SPAZIO E IMMAGINE IN LAS MENINAS DI DIEGO VELÃZQUEZ