Evaluation of Surgical Instruments With Radiofrequency Identification Tags in the Operating Room

Kazuhiko Yamashita,Kaori Kusuda,Yoshitomo Ito,Masaru Komino,Kiyohito Tanaka,Satoru Kurokawa,Michitaka Ameya,Daiji Eba,Ken Masamune,Yoshihiro Muragaki,Yuji Ohta,Chugo Rinoie,Kenji Yamada,Yoshiki Sawa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1553350618772771
2018-05-02
Surgical Innovation
Abstract:Background. Surgical instrument retention and instrument breakage compromise surgery quality and lead to medical malpractice. We developed an instrument tracking system that could alert surgeons to instrument retention during surgery and monitor instrument use to reduce the risk of breakage. Methods. This prospective, experimental clinical trial included 15 patients undergoing inguinal hernia surgery or lumpectomy under general anesthesia at Saiseikai Kurihashi Hospital. Radiofrequency identification (RFID)-tagged surgical instruments were used, and a detection antenna was placed on a mayo stand during the operation. We analyzed the 1-loop detection ratio (OLDR)—that is, the capability of the antenna to detect devices in a single reading—and the total detection rate (TDR)—that is, the data accumulated for the duration of the operation—of the RFID-tagged instruments. Results. Data analysis revealed that the OLDR was 95% accurate, whereas the TDR was 100% accurate. The antenna could not detect the RFID tag when there was interference from electrocautery noise radiation, and 6% of instrument movement was undetected by the antenna; however, the TDR and instrument use were detected at all times. Conclusions. Surgical instruments can be tracked during surgery, and this tracking can clarify the usage rate of each instrument and serve as a backup method of instrument counting. However, this study was conducted on a small scale, and RFID tags cannot be attached to small surgical instruments used in complex operations such as neurosurgery. Further efforts to develop a tracking system for these instruments are warranted.
surgery
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the problems of surgical instruments being left in the patient's body cavity during the operation and being damaged during the use. These problems not only affect the quality of the operation, but may also lead to medical accidents. The author has developed a surgical instrument tracking system with radio - frequency identification (RFID) tags to remind surgeons to pay attention to instrument retention during the operation and monitor the use of instruments, thereby reducing the risk of breakage. Specifically, the objective of the study is to evaluate the tracking rate of commonly used surgical instruments with RFID tags detected by antennas in the operating room and verify the effectiveness of RFID - tagged surgical instruments. Through this study, the author hopes to provide a method that can improve the accuracy of surgical instrument counting, avoid leaving instruments in the body, prevent surgical instrument breakage, and thus improve the quality of the operation and patient safety. The paper mentions that although there are currently preventive measures such as routine manual counting of surgical instruments, incidents of surgical instruments being left in the patient's body still occur from time to time. Therefore, it is particularly important to develop more reliable technical means to monitor and manage the use of surgical instruments.