Abstract:Purpose Given the importance of performance consistency of chain hotels in customers' decision-making and service evaluation, this study aims to explore how consistently chain hotel brands offer quality service and carry out their performance from the eyes of customers through online reviews on TripAdvisor of the top five US hotel chains (i.e. Choice, Hilton, InterContinental, Marriott and Wyndham) and their brands. Design/methodology/approach The research objectives were achieved through methodological triangulation: business intelligence, data visualization analytics and statistical analyses. First, the data collection and pre-processing of consumer-generated media (CGM) (i.e. TripAdvisor online reviews) were performed using business intelligence for further analyses. Using data visualization analytics (i.e. box-and-whisker plot by region and brand), the geographic patterns of performance attributes (i.e. online review ratings, including location, sleep, cleanliness, room and service) were depicted. Using a series of analyses of variance and regression analyses, the results were further assessed for the impacts of brand performance inconsistency on consumers' perceived value, sentiment and satisfaction. Findings The empirical results demonstrate that there are significant performance inconsistencies in performance attributes (location, sleep, cleanliness, room and service) by brands throughout the six regions in the US hotel market. More importantly, the findings confirm that brand performance consistency significantly influences consumers' perceived service quality (i.e. perceived value, satisfaction and sentiment). Originality This study is one of the first attempts to empirically explore hotel brand performance consistency in the US hotel market from customer reviews on CGM. To measure hotel brand performance in the US hotel market, this study collected and analyzed user-generated big data for the top 5 US hotel chains through business intelligence, visualization analytics and statistical analysis. These integrated and novel research methods would help tourism and hospitality researchers analyze big data in an innovative data analytics approach. The findings of the study contribute to the tourism and hospitality field by confirming hotel brand performance inconsistency and such inconsistent performance affected customers' service evaluations. Practical Implications This study demonstrates the significant impact of hotel brand performance consistency on consumers' perceived value, emotion and satisfaction. Considering that online reviews are perceived as a credible source of information, the findings suggest that the hotel industry pays special attention to brand performance consistency to improve consumers' perceived value, emotion and satisfaction.

Transforming Brand Identity to Hotel Performance: The Moderating Effect of Social Capital

What Makes Social Media Branding More Effective in Shaping Pre-Visit Image: Information Quality or Source Credibility?

Assessing the moderating roles of brand equity, intellectual capital and social capital in Chinese luxury hotels

Hotel brand equity and online reviews on social commerce intention: A cross-level identification process

Enhancing Hotel Employees’ Brand Understanding and Brand-Building Behavior in China

A new path for building hotel brand equity: the impacts of technological competence and service innovation implementation through perceived value and trust

Impact of Luxury Hotel Customer Experience on Brand Love and Customer Citizenship Behavior

The Influence of Hotel Brand Image in Social Media Marketing on Consumer Purchase Behavior

Investigating the Impacts of Hotel Brand Experience on Brand Loyalty: The Mediating Role of Brand Positioning

An Empirical Study Of Customer-Based Brand Equity Model For China Economy Hotels

Hotel guests’ social commerce intention

Can Environmentally Sustainable Development and Green Innovation of Hotels Trigger the Formation of a Positive Brand and Price Premium?

Effects of Sustainable Brand Equity and Marketing Innovation on Market Performance in Hospitality Industry: Mediating Effects of Sustainable Competitive Advantage

Promoting Responsible Sustainable Consumer Behavior through Sustainability Marketing: The Boundary Effects of Corporate Social Responsibility and Brand Image

The Effects of Psychological Capital and Internal Social Capital on Frontline Hotel Employees’ Adaptive Performance

Assessing brand performance consistency from consumer-generated media: the US hotel industry

An Examination of Social Media Marketing in China: How do the Top 133 Hotel Brands Perform on the Top Four Chinese Social Media Sites?

Employer Brand and Business Performance: The Role of Intellectual Capital

In China, customer engagement mediates between brand image and purchase intention of premium hotels

Exploring the impact of social media platform image on hotel customers’ visit intention

Customer Experience and Brand Loyalty in the Full-Service Hotel Sector: the Role of Brand Affect