Abstract:After many years of research across disciplines, it remains unclear whether people are more motivated to seek appraisals that accurately match self-views (self-verification) or are as favorable as possible (self-enhancement). Within sociology, mixed findings in identity theory have fueled the debate. A problem here is that a commonly employed statistical approach does not take into account the direction of a discrepancy between how we see ourselves and how we think others see us in terms of a given identity, yet doing so is critical for determining which self-motive is at play. We offer a test of three competing models of identity processes, including a new "mixed motivations" model where self-verification and self-enhancement operate simultaneously. We compare the models using the conventional statistical approach versus response surface analysis. The latter method allows us to determine whether identity discrepancies involving over-evaluation are as distressing as those involving under-evaluation. We use nationally representative data and compare results across four different identities and multiple outcomes. The two statistical approaches lead to the same conclusions more often than not and mostly support identity theory and its assumption that people seek self-verification. However, response surface tests reveal patterns that are mistaken as evidence of self-verification by conventional procedures, especially for the spouse identity. We also find that identity discrepancies have different effects on distress and self-conscious emotions (guilt and shame). Our findings have implications not only for research on self and identity across disciplines, but also for many other areas of research that incorporate these concepts and/or use difference scores as explanatory variables.

Aspects of identity: From the inner-outer metaphor to a tetrapartite model of the self

Understanding identity integration: Theoretical, methodological, and applied issues

Disentangling self-concept clarity and self-esteem in young adults.

Aspects of Identity Questionnaire-IV: An Examination of Structural Validity, Gender Invariance, and Relationships with Mental Health and Basic Psychological Needs Among Adolescents

Circumplex of identity formation modes: A proposal for the integration of identity constructs developed in the Erikson–Marcia tradition

Theoretical Analysis of the Concept „Identity“, Basic Components and their Special Aspects

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

The Past, Present, and Future of an Identity Theory*

Associations of Identity Dimensions with Big Five Personality Domains and Facets

Empirical verification of the circumplex of identity formation modes and its potential to integrate different models of identity development in the Erikson–Marcia tradition

The Structure of Identity Dysfunction in Self-Report Measures

Achieving Harmony among Different Social Identities within the Self-Concept: The Consequences of Internalising a Group-Based Philosophy of Life

A motivational approach to self: Integration in personality.

Human Nature in Self-Identity Construct: A Meta-ethnography Study

The Social Self: On Being the Same and Different at the Same Time

Comparisons Inform Me Who I Am: A General Comparative-Processing Model of Self-Perception

We Do What We Are: Representation of the Self-Concept and Identity-Based Choice

In the Jungle of Time: the Concept of Identity As a Way Out

A Deep Dig into the Feature of “situational Selves” of Online Identity: A Review of the Concept/Theory of “situational Selves”

Identity Integration:The Pathway to Internal Harmony

Agency and Identity in the Collective Self