Abstract:Increasing automation calls for evaluating the effectiveness and intelligence of automated vehicles. This paper proposes a framework for quantitatively evaluating the intelligence of automated vehicles. Firstly, we establish the evaluation environment for automated vehicles including test field, test task, and evaluation index. The test tasks include the single vehicle decision-making (turning, lane-changing, overtaking, etc.) and the maneuver execution of multi-vehicle interaction (obstacle avoidance, trajectory optimization, etc.). The intelligence evaluation index is the action amount of driving process considering the safety, efficiency, rationality and comfort. Then, we calculate the actual action amount of the automated vehicle in different scenarios in the test field. Finally, the least action calculated theoretically corresponds to the highest intelligence degree of the automated vehicle, and is employed as a standard to quantify the performance of other tested automated vehicles. The effectiveness of this framework is verified with two naturalistic driving datasets that contain the normal driving scenarios and high-risk scenarios. Specifically, the naturalistic lane-changing data filters 40,416 frames and 179 similar lane-changing trajectories. Compared with the lane-changing behavior of a large number of drivers, experimental results verify that the proposed algorithm can achieve the intelligence degree of drivers in the lane change scenario. Meanwhile, in 253 reconstructed high-risk scenarios, the intelligent risk avoidance ability of the proposed intelligence degree evaluation algorithm can be verified by comparing with the driver behavior and TTC algorithm. These experimental results show that the proposed framework can effectively quantify intelligence and evaluate the performance of automated vehicles under various scenarios.

A test and evaluation method for autonomous vehicle following system

Test and evaluation of autonomous ground vehicles

Integrated Framework for Test and Evaluation of Autonomous Vehicles

An Evaluation Method for Automated Vehicles Combining Subjective and Objective Factors

Autonomous Vehicle Following System In Off-Road Environment

An Improved Grey Relational Theory Evaluation Method: Considering the Comprehensive Performance of Autonomous Vehicles in Virtual Test

An Evaluation System Based on User Big Data Management and Artificial Intelligence for Automatic Vehicles

Testing and Evaluation of Autonomous Vehicles Based on Safety of the Intended Functionality

Scalable Evaluation Methods for Autonomous Vehicles

Scenario-based Accelerated Testing for SOTIF in Autonomous Driving: A Review

Control Evaluation System Testing of Distributed Drive Electric Vehicle Handling Stability

Control Model of Automated Driving Systems Based on SOTIF Evaluation

Evaluating Roadside Perception for Autonomous Vehicles: Insights from Field Testing

Performance Evaluation Method for Automated Driving System in Logical Scenario

Evaluation method with digital expert on the criticality of car-following scenarios for autonomous vehicles testing

Accelerated Testing and Evaluation of Autonomous Vehicles Based on Dual Surrogates

The Implementation of Safety Acceptance Evaluation for Highly Automated Vehicles

Autonomous Vehicles’ Car-Following Drivability Evaluation Based on Driving Behavior Spectrum Reference Model

An Integrated Architecture for Intelligence Evaluation of Automated Vehicles.

A Multi-dimensional Evaluation Criterion Scheme for Autonomous Vehicles: Behavioral Performance

Adaptive Cruise Control System Evaluation According to Human Driving Behavior Characteristics