Achieving Sustainable Development
John Robinson,A. Dale
2002-04-01
Abstract:Viewed on a day in late June 1997, Metropolitan Toronto stretches north and is lost in a yellow haze -- an import, in part, from Ohio mills and power plants. News reports that day told not only of smog, but of a UV alert, and of the failure of the Earth Summit, 1997 edition, that week in New York. Less than a month before, the environment had played only a bit part in the federal election campaign, appearing as menace, in the form of a swollen Red River. Such weighty matters as national unity and jobs evidently could be discussed as if they related not at all to a landscape that has shaped our national story, and that remains a foundation of both production (forests, fish, food) and consumption (especially tourism). Perhaps we really can take air, water and land for granted, at least until prodded from the south -- by floodwaters, dirty winds or news of a failed conference.But this apparent dependence on environmental imperatives from elsewhere is not entirely accurate. During the last 25 years a distinctive Canadian environmental politics has emerged, played out through diverse environmental institutions and perspectives, and reacting with our profligate use of resources, and with changes in the global environment. This emergence has been chronicled by a substantial academic literature, providing interpretations of the recent history of Canadian environmental politics, explorations of contemporary environmental issues and conflicts and projections of potential sustainable futures for Canada.Imperfect PastsMost of the institutions of contemporary Canadian environmental politics came into existence in the late 1960s or early 1970s. Environment Canada led the way: cobbled together from both existing and new federal units, it owed its existence to an expanded sense of government responsibilities, the ambitions of federal bureaucrats and politicians, and pressure from environmentalists and an alarmed public. G. Brace Doern and Thomas Conway provide in The Greening of Canada: Federal Institutions and Decisions a highly useful account of this complex entity, from its origins in the late 1960s to the implementation of the Green Plan of the early 1990s, and the Earth Summit in 1992. Drawing on an array of published and unpublished government documents, as well as interviews with many of those involved in the events described, Doern and Conway provide essentially a history of Environment Canada, that should be of interest to anyone seeking to understand how federal environmental policy is formulated and implemented. While focussing on Environment Canada, they also explore the context of federal environmental policy making: the relations of Environment Canada with other, often more powerful federal departments; with the provinces, business and environmental interests: and with international institutions and other nations. And beyond this human context of decisions and actions, as Doern and Conway acknowledge, is the natural environment, imposing its own, often unpredictable dynamic on environmental politics.Whether evaluated in terms of specific actions for protecting the environment, or in terms of defining an overall federal environmental mission, Environment Canada's record has been mixed. But as Doern and Conway explain, the obstacles faced by the department make any success seem almost remarkable. Sixteen ministers in its first 22 years hindered efforts to establish a longterm, coherent agenda for the department. These ministers also exhibited widely varying levels of competence and commitment. Some, both Liberal (such as the first minister, Jack Davis), and Conservative (for example, Lucien Bouchard and Robert de Cotret, who helped push the Green Plan through the Ottawa system) put their stamps on federal environmental policies, while others were disastrous, or simply ineffective.The challenge posed by frequent ministerial changes (itself reflecting the low status of Environment Canada within the federal government) was sharpened by centrifugal forces created when the department was brought into existence. …
Environmental Science,Sociology