Gender and Family in Contemporary China
yu xie
2013-01-01
Abstract:Both gender relations and family structures have undergone tremendous changes since the founding of the People’s Republic of China in 1949. This article reviews the recent literature on gender and family in contemporary China, focusing on social changes. As a whole, research has shown both radical departures from, as well as a continuation of, traditional practices concerning gender relations and the family. Examples of departures include women’s significant improvement in socioeconomic status relative to that of men, rises in premarital cohabitation and divorce, and elderly no longer depending on sons for old-age support. Examples of continued traditions include wife’s primary housework role, social hypergamy, multi-generational coresidence, and substantial son-preference. In recent years, rapid economic development and the associated high consumption aspirations have exerted economic pressures on young persons entering marriage. Gender and Family in Contemporary China 3 Traditional Chinese Family and Gender Roles Family, a group of individuals connected by either marriage or blood, is the most elementary social, economic, and residential collective unit in most human societies. While family as a social institution is universal, its manifestation and significance vary both across societies and over time. Ample evidence indicates that the traditional Chinese family, in its ideal form, is different from the “modern family” that evolved from Western Europe. One distinct feature of the traditional Chinese family is the paramount importance of family lineage (Chu and Yu 2010). In this tradition, individuals are no more than temporary carriers who perpetuate familial male lines, with ancestors assuming spiritual roles. Ancestors are believed to be active in their afterlives and need to be worshiped, offered, and respected through family rituals. In return, they provide protection and assistance to their living offspring. Thus, ancestors assume a god-like status in Chinese culture, with each large family clan essentially having its own folk religion (Thompson 1989). The god-like status of ancestors also carries practical implications for everyday life in the form of filial piety. The core value in the Chinese family, filial piety requires that children or grandchildren respect and care for their parents or grandparents (Thornton and Lin 1994; Whyte 2004). The traditional Chinese family has long been characterized as patriarchal, patrimonial, patrilineal, and patrilocal, putting women at a severe social disadvantage relative to men (Thornton and Lin 1994). Indeed, in a classic paper on the influence of Chinese family structure on gender inequality, Greenhalgh (1985, p.265) stated that “Traditional Confucian China and its cultural offshoots, Japan and Korea, evolved some of the most patriarchal family systems that ever existed.” There are rational bases for this gender inequality. In this family system, sons are permanent members of their natal family and retain life-time financial relationships with their parents. They are expected to contribute to their parents’ economic well-being even after they are married themselves. Thus, it is in their self-interest for parents to invest in sons because they may reap long-term returns from this investment. In contrast, daughters are only temporary members of their natal families before marriage, upon which a woman serves her husband’s extended family (Whyte and Xu 2003). Thus, due to the limited time during which daughters serve their natal families, parents often extract resources from unmarried daughters, for example in terms of remittances from daughters’ market labor or housework, to improve the family budget and invest in sons. In Greenhalgh’s (1985, p.276) words, “Put baldly, parents’ key strategy was to take more from daughters to give more to sons and thus get more for themselves.” Gender and Family in Contemporary China 4 Empirical Evidence and Social Changes Researchers have found empirical evidence, mostly based on data from Taiwan, to illustrate the traditional Chinese family system. For example, two studies report that Taiwanese families tend to sacrifice older daughters’ educations to benefit the educational outcomes of younger sons (Chu, Xie, and Yu 2007; Parish and Willis 1993). Furthermore, several studies have found that married sons provide larger amounts of financial support than married daughters to elderly parents in Taiwan (Hermalin, Ofstedal, and Shih 2003; Lee, Parish, and Willis 1994; Lin et al. 2003) and in rural China (Yang, 1996). More evidence is given in books by Chu and Yu (2010) and Thornton and Lin (1994). China has undergone major social changes in the last six decades, due to several revolutionary movements, most notably the Communist Revolution that resulted in the founding of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in1949, the 1966-1976 Cultural Revolution, and the economic reform that began in 1978. In 1950, China instituted the Marriage Law, which formally legalized free-choice marriages and explicitly equalized wives’ rights and interests with those of husbands. As I will show below, changes in education, the pension system, and economic structure have also greatly altered family life in contemporary China. There are also good indications that a substantial fraction of Chinese parents today, especially educated ones, no longer subscribe to the traditional Chinese value of maintaining family lineage (Wu and Xie 2013). Gender Inequality in Contemporary China Since the founding of the PRC in 1949, women’s socioeconomic status has significantly improved. This is most significantly shown in education. While women’s education fell far below that of men in the early years of the PRC, women’s educational attainment has gradually caught up with that of men (Hannum and Xie 1994; Li and Xie 2013; Wu and Zhang 2010). For instance, in 1982, the percentages receiving postsecondary education were respectively 1.24% for men and 0.64% for women; these percentages increased to 6.72% and 5.63% in 2005 (Mu and Xie forthcoming). Women’s employment has been nearly universal throughout the history of the PRC, although severe occupation segregation has persisted for non-agricultural jobs over time (Wu and Wu 2008). Although the gender gap in earnings was low among urban workers, especially educated urban workers, in the early years of the reform era (Xie and Hannum 1996), the gender gap has increased over time (Hauser and Xie 2005). A recent study based on data from 2010 and 2012 estimates women’s earnings to be 70% those of men, without any controls (Li and Xie 2013). The same study also reports gender differences, in favor of men, in middleand higher-level administrative/managerial positions and political participation. Gender and Family in Contemporary China 5 An explanation of the paradox of women’s large improvement in educational attainment being accompanied by lower economic standing for women than for men, especially for high-level positions, lies not only in the labor market but also in the family. Yu and Xie (2012) report large gender gaps in household work in contemporary China, with the lion’s share falling on the shoulders of the wife rather than the husband. It is quite possible that this traditional division of labor in the household, with women being mainly responsible for caring for children and the household, may impede realization of women’s full potential in the labor market.