Abstract:Purpose Challenging the static view of family business governance, we propose a model of owner–manager relationships derived from the configurational analysis of managerial behavior and change in governance structure. Design/methodology/approach Stemming from social exchange theory and building on the 4C model proposed by Miller and Le Breton-Miller (2005), we consider the evolving owner–manager relationship in four main configurations. On the one hand, we account for family businesses shifting from a generalized to a restricted exchange system, and vice versa, according to whether a family manager misbehaves in a stewardship-oriented governance structure or a nonfamily manager succeeds in building a trusting relationship in an agency-oriented governance structure. On the other hand, we consider that family firms will strengthen a generalized exchange system, rather than a restricted one, according to whether a family manager contributes to the stewardship-oriented culture in the business or a nonfamily manager proves to be driven by extrinsic rewards. Four scenarios are analyzed in terms of the managerial behavior and governance structure that characterize the phases of the relationship between owners and managers. Findings Various factors trigger managerial behavior, making the firm deviate from or further build on what is assumed by stewardship and agency theories (i.e. proorganizational versus opportunistic behavior, respectively), which determine the governance structure over time. Workplace deviance, asymmetric altruism and patriarchy on the one hand, and proorganizational behavior, relationship building and long-term commitment on the other, are found to determine how the manager behaves and thus characterize the owner's reactions in terms of governance mechanisms. This enables us to present a dynamic view of governance structures, which adapt to the actual attitudes and behaviors of employed managers. Research limitations/implications As time is a relevant dimension affecting individual behavior and triggering change in an organization, one must consider family business governance as being dynamic in nature. Moreover, it is not family membership that determines the most appropriate governance structure but the owner–manager relationship that evolves over time, thus contributing to the 4C model. Originality/value The proposed model integrates social exchange theory and the 4C model to predict changes in governance structure, as summarized in the final framework we propose.

Stewardship Theory of Corporate Governance and Value System: The Case of a Family-owned Business Group in India

Private Listed Companies in China:Family Governance and Firm Value

Family Firms, Corporate Governance and Performance: Evidence from Zhejiang

Research on the Evolution of Family Governance in Ethnic Chinese Business Groups-A Case Study of Columbia Group from Indonesia

Family business governance: An integrated approach using agency, stewardship, and social capital theories

When Does Family Ownership Promote Proactive Environmental Strategy? the Role of the Firm’s Long-Term Orientation

The Importance of the Governance Role in Achieving Stability and Sustainability in Family Business Companies Through Generations

Corporate governance and family business: a perspective article

Governance Structure Theories for Family Business

Beyond agency and stewardship theory: shareholder–manager relationships and governance structures in family firms

Explicating the contextuality of corporate governance through ownership structure and family management: evidence from an emerging economy

Impact of effective governance structure on succession process in the family business: exploring the mediating role of management succession planning

Does Family Management Improve Family Business Value? An Empirical Study on Listed Family Firms in Small and Medium Enterprise Board

The Influence of Family Governance on the Value of Chinese Family Businesses: Signal Transmission Effect of Financial Performance

The pitfalls of corporate social irresponsibility: Hypocrisy of family firms in South Korea

Essays on Corporate Governance and Firm Performance

Impact of Ownership Structure and Board Characteristics on Firm Value: Evidence From China and India

The Family That Prays Together Stays Together: Toward a Process Model of Religious Value Transmission in Family Firms

An empirical investigation of the influence of leadership styles and strategic decision-making on business performance: a generational ownership perspective

Ownership structure and corporate social responsibility in India: empirical investigation of an emerging market

A comparative study of corporate governance practices of Indian firms affiliated to business groups and industries