Abstract:Large databases of cyclic tests on flexure‐ or shear‐critical concrete members and shear‐critical connections of columns to beams or slabs are used to estimate the uncertainty inherent in experimental data in literature—as read by users. To this end, the predictions of two different, presumably independent, design‐oriented models for the properties of interest are used to establish the "central tendency" of data, against which individual tests or small groups thereof are assessed. Properties considered are: (a) the cyclic ultimate chord‐rotation of flexure‐controlled members with continuous or lap‐spliced deformed bars, (b) the cyclic shear strength of shear‐critical members, (c) the chord‐rotation at yielding of rectangular columns with plain bars, and (d) the cyclic shear strength of shear‐controlled beam‐column and slab‐column joints. Results suggest that the data from each test campaign have a certain degree of bias, specific to it. Test campaigns with ratio of estimated average deviation from the "central tendency" to the standard deviation of campaign deviations (called "data uncertainty") which is far into the tail of the Normal distribution may be excluded as questionable. This systematic bias, along with other types of "data uncertainty" addressed in this work, seem to contribute to the apparent scatter of model predictions with respect to cyclic test results the equivalent of a coefficient of variation of model‐to‐test‐ratio of at least 10% and possibly as high as 25%–30%. Model uncertainty seems to contribute to this scatter the equivalent of a coefficient of variation of at least 15% in shear‐controlled connections, or as much as 25% in the case of flexural deformation capacity of members with deformed bars; the cyclic shear resistance of members and—with the reservation of the small number of tests—the chord‐rotation at yielding of members with plain bars, are in‐between.

Model uncertainties in numerical simulations of reinforced concrete structures

Finite Element Modelling of Two-way RC Slabs with Varying Modelling Choices

Model uncertainty in non‐linear numerical analyses of slender reinforced concrete members

Numerical simulation of concrete structures—From research to engineering application

Resistance model uncertainty in non-linear finite element analyses of cyclically loaded reinforced concrete systems

Model uncertainties in action effects and load bearing capacity calculation in statically indeterminate reinforced concrete structures

Validation study on numerical simulation of RC response to close-in blast with a fully coupled model

Quantification of the resistance modeling uncertainty of 19 alternative 2D nonlinear finite element approaches benchmarked against 101 experiments on reinforced concrete beams

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF FAILURE BEHAVIOR OF REINFORCED CONCRETE FRAME STRUCTURES BY DISCRETE ELEMENT METHOD

Numerically Efficient Three-Dimensional Model for Non-Linear Finite Element Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Structures

Approaches to estimate global safety factors for reliability assessment of RC structures using non-linear numerical analyses

Numerical-based method for calculating reinforcement corrosion at concrete cover cracking due to corrosion

3D meso‐scale numerical model and dynamic mechanical behavior of reinforced concrete

Numerical Modeling and Analysis of Concrete Slabs in Interaction with Subsoil

Stochastic finite element modeling of heterogeneities in massive concrete and reinforced concrete structures

Numerical Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Slab with Subsoil

Nonlinear global design resistance: Case studies of post‐tensioned concrete bridges made of I‐73 and KA‐61 girders

Performance Assessment of Concrete and Steel Material Models in LS-DYNA for Enhanced Numerical Simulation, A State of the Art Review

A meso-scale analysis method for the simulation of nonlinear damage and failure behavior of reinforced concrete members

Modeling inelastic behavior of U-shaped walls using multi-layer shell element: assessment at both global and local levels

Model‐ versus data‐uncertainty for concrete members and connections in cyclic loading