Abstract:At the remote UNESCO Word Heritage Site Te Wāhipounamu, we show that eDNA analysis is a highly sensitive tool with strong potential for biodiversity surveys, which is still limited by the unavailability of local reference data. We hope that by demonstrating the extend of divergence between eDNA and more traditional tools in a real‐life case study of a remote region of high conservation interest, we further strengthen the case to fund the establishment of local eDNA reference data, also to benefit Te Wāhipounamu. Effective management of biodiversity requires regular surveillance of multiple species. Analysis of environmental DNA (eDNA) by metabarcoding holds promise to achieve this relatively easily. However, taxonomy‐focused eDNA surveys need suitable molecular reference data, which are often lacking, particularly at the species level and for remote locations. To evaluate the comparability of environmental DNA surveys and traditional surveys in a real‐life case study in a marine area of high conservation value, we conducted a biodiversity survey of the fish in remote and pristine Te Wāhipounamu/Fiordland (Aotearoa/New Zealand), incorporating multiple data sources. We compared eDNA‐derived species identifications against Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) data collected at the same time and locations as eDNA. We also cross‐referenced both eDNA and BRUV data against literature and the Ocean Biodiversity Information System (OBIS), with literature and OBIS data representing a summary of multiple traditional surveying approaches. In total, we found 116 fish species in our study area. Environmental DNA detected 43 species; however, only three of those species overlap with species known from the literature, OBIS, or our BRUV analyses. A total of 61 fish species were known from the region from the literature, while OBIS listed 28 species, and our BRUV analyses picked up 26 species. BRUV data coincided more strongly than eDNA data with literature and OBIS data. Twenty of the 26 species detected by BRUV were known from literature and OBIS. We argue that limitated DNA reference databases are the main cause of this discrepancy, and our results indicate that eDNA of rare and endangered species can be detected if matching reference data were available. Environmental DNA analyses can only identify species present among reference data and with relaxed taxonomic assignment parameters may converge on relatives of detected species if the actually existing species themselves are missing among reference data. However, the high number of species detected by our eDNA analyses confirms that eDNA could be a powerful tool for biodiversity surveys if suitable investments in local reference databases were made.

Subsistence practices, past biodiversity, and anthropogenic impacts revealed by New Zealand-wide ancient DNA survey

It is time for ancient DNA to sweat the small stuff

The New Zealand biota: Historical background and new research

Fossil-calibrated phylogenies of Southern cave wētā show dispersal and extinction confound biogeographic signal

Comparison of traditional and molecular surveys of fish biodiversity in southern Te Wāhipounamu/Fiordland (Aotearoa/New Zealand)

Reconstructing colonization dynamics to establish how human activities transformed island biodiversity

Biogeography and History of the Prehuman Native Mammal Fauna of the New Zealand Region

Whole-Genome Genetic Diversity in a Sample of Australians with Deep Aboriginal Ancestry

Ecological dynamics of moa extinctions reveal convergent refugia that today harbour flightless birds

Molecular identification of whales remains from the Keller Peninsula, Admiralty Bay, King George Island, Antarctica

Ancient DNA and the human settlement of the Pacific: A review

Ancient mitochondrial genomes recovered from small vertebrate bones through minimally destructive DNA extraction: Phylogeography of the New Zealand gecko genus Hoplodactylus

Ancient and modern environmental DNA

Species-wide genomics of kākāpō provides tools to accelerate recovery

Ancient DNA and deep population structure in sub-Saharan African foragers

Species-specific responses of Late Quaternary megafauna to climate and humans

The half-life of DNA in bone: Measuring decay kinetics in 158 dated fossils

Genomic insights into the peopling of the Southwest Pacific

Collapse of the mammoth-steppe in central Yukon as revealed by ancient environmental DNA

Life in ruins: DNA metabarcoding contributes to the history of Whalers Bay wooden structures at Deception Island, South Shetland Islands

Wetland biodiversity in Aotearoa New Zealand: an eDNA perspective on exotic and non-exotic species