Perception of Sibling Relationships and Birth Order Among Asian American and European American Emerging Adults

Kaidi Wu,Jacqueline H. J. Kim,Donna K. Nagata,Stephanie I. Kim
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0192513x18783465
2018-07-11
Journal of Family Issues
Abstract:Drawing from an ecological systems framework, we qualitatively explored how Confucian-heritage Asian American emerging adults compared with non-Hispanic European American emerging adults on views of sibling relationships and birth order. Thematic analysis of 48 semi-structured interviews revealed positive sibling relationship themes for both ethnocultural groups: mutual support, companionship, and appreciation; comfort from shared burden of negative parental interactions; and pride in one another. Birth-order themes were also similar across the groups. First-borns overall reported a strong pressure to be a role model to later-borns, provide sibling care, assume family responsibilities, and not expect to rely on younger siblings. Despite these similarities, Asian American first-borns were unique in taking comfort in having siblings who shared a less traditional Asian cultural perspective than their parents. They also described additional pressure from being the oldest within an immigrant family.
family studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?