Abstract:Previous research has long paid attention to how to improve persuasive effectiveness in charitable donation. Based on moral foundation theory (MFT) and stereotype content model (SCM), this paper proposes that a match between moral appeal and social perception leads higher persuasive effectiveness of individual donation. More specifically, relative to those who are exposed to a binding appeal, consumers who are exposed to an individualizing appeal are more willing to donate for warmth-oriented organizations. However, for competence-oriented organizations, a binding appeal will garner higher persuasive effectiveness than an individualizing appeal. Furthermore, two types of efficacy (i.e., self-efficacy and response efficacy) mediate the interaction effect of moral appeal and social perception on donation effectiveness. Three lab experiments were conducted to examine these hypotheses. In particular, experiment 1 employed a 3 (moral appeal: binding appeal vs. individualizing appeal vs. neutral) x 2 (social perception: warmth-oriented vs. competence-oriented) two-way between-subjects design. We found that competence-oriented (vs. warmth-oriented) organizations will obtain better donation persuasion results when consumers are exposed to binding (vs. individualizing) appeal, supporting the hypotheses H1a and H1b. Then, in experiment 2, we identified the underlying mechanism, such that the interaction effect is driven by consumers' response efficacy and self-efficacy, verifying the hypotheses H2a and H2b. Experiment 3 further examined the mediating role of different types of efficacy using a moderation approach. Participants were randomly assigned to one of condition of 3 (moral appeal: binding appeal vs. individualizing appeal vs. neutral) x 2 (social perception: warmth-oriented vs. competence-oriented) x 2 (efficacy: self-efficacy vs. response efficacy). Experiment 3 replicated the findings of previous experiments, showing the robustness of our conclusions. We also ruled out some alternative explanations (e.g., empathy) in the study. Theoretically, this research observes for the first time the interactive effect of moral appeal and social perception, thus extending both moral foundation theory and stereotype content model. The current study also enriches existing donation literature by examining the mediating role of response efficacy and self-efficacy. Managerially, this research has rich implications to charitable organization and companies when they aim to improve persuasive effectiveness in an individual donation.

An Empirical Study on the Promotion of Donation Performance of Non-profit Organizations-Emotional Influence on the Willingness to Donate

Research on the Charity and Donation Behavior of Corporations

Altruism or Social Motives? Evidence from Online Charitable Giving in China.

Digital Economy and Private Donation Behavior: an Empirical Analysis Based on the CFPS Data

Empirical Analysis of Charitable Donation in China:Factor Analysis Based on the Experimental Data

Understanding people's participation in online charities: a dual-process approach of trust and empathic concern

Factors Impacting Donors' Intention To Donate To Charitable Crowd-Funding Projects In China: A Utaut-Based Model

Understanding the intention to donate online in the Chinese context: The influence of norms and trust

Do Promotions Make Consumers More Generous? the Impact of Price Promotions on Consumers’ Donation Behavior

Why Do People Support Online Crowdfunding Charities? A Case Study from China.

Individual Fundraising in Online Charitable Giving

The Effects of Nonprofit Brand Equity on Individual Giving Intention: Mediating by the Self-Concept of Individual Donor

Empirical Research on Influence of Mission Statements on the Performance of Nonprofit Organization

The Impact of Information Disclosure and the Incentive Mechanism on Individual Intertemporal Committed Donation:An Experiment Study

A study on the influencing factors of the public’s willingness to donate funds for critical illness crowdfunding projects on network platforms

The impact of congruency between moral appeal and social perception on charitable donation

Institutional Environment, Organizational Slack and Behaviors Difference: An Empirical Study of Comparison Between Local and Foreign Donors' Motivation

How Facial Expressions of Recipients Influence Online Prosocial Behaviors? - Evidence from Big Data Analysis on Tencent Gongyi Platform.

A study on the influence of personality characteristics on household charitable donation behavior in China

Click to contribute: understanding donation behaviour and well-being in donation-based crowdfunding mobile apps

Fundraising in the Digital Era: Legitimacy, Social Network, and Political Ties Matter in China