Abstract:AbstractThis study investigates how security analysts' response to focal firms' corporate social responsibility (CSR) strategies varies with the level of CSR engagement among peer firms, about which contradictory arguments can be drawn from the perspectives of legitimacy and competitive dynamics. Legitimacy theory underscores the importance of conformity to peers' behaviors, while the competitive dynamics perspective suggests that firms should differentiate from their peers. The optimal distinctiveness theory suggests an orchestration between CSR conformity and CSR differentiation, combining the arguments of legitimacy and competitive dynamics. Based upon a sample of Chinese listed companies from 2009 to 2018, this study uses a second‐hand panel dataset and employs three‐way interactions and the generalized method of moments (GMM) system. The empirical results show that as CSR engagement among peer firms increases, heavier legitimacy pressure is imposed on focal firms, and their CSR scope conformity attracts more analyst coverage, and this effect is more prominent for firms in institutionally developed regions. On the other hand, the competitive advantage gained from CSR emphasis differentiation is weakened by rivals' engagement in CSR, and the influence of CSR emphasis differentiation on analyst recommendation is weakened by peers' CSR engagement, and in highly competitive industries, this effect of peers' CSR engagement is stronger. We propose that peers' CSR engagement has different impacts on the importance of CSR conformity and differentiation. Finally, both the theoretical and practical implications are discussed.

Does social responsibility begin at home? The relation between firms’ pension policies and corporate social responsibility (CSR) activities

Corporate Social Responsibility, Pension Assumptions, and Risky Asset Allocations in Defined Benefit Pension Plans

Internal Governance and Corporate Social Responsibility: Evidence from Chinese Companies

Corporate Social Responsibility and Its Impact on Firms’ Investment Policy, Organizational Structure, and Performance

Do firms walk the talk when economic uncertainty is high?

Sustainable Strategies: Navigating Corporate Social Responsibility and Irresponsibility for Enlightened Self-Interest

Does CSR reputation mitigate the impact of corporate social irresponsibility?

Does share pledging promote or impede corporate social responsibility? An examination of Chinese listed firms

A Stakeholder Resource-Based View of Corporate Social Irresponsibility: Evidence from China

CSR by Any Other Name? The Differential Impact of Substantive and Symbolic CSR Attributions on Employee Outcomes

Still Dare to Be Different? Peers' CSR Engagement and Analysts' Response to Focal Firms' CSR Strategies

Prize or Price? Corporate Social Responsibility Commitment and Sales Performance in the Chinese Private Sector

Impact of CSR on stock return resilience during the 2020 public health emergency: Evidence from the Chinese financial market

A Buffer or a Liability? Double-Edged Sword Effect of Ex Ante CSR Communication

Did Corporate Social Responsibility Vaccinate Corporations Against COVID-19?

Chinese Consumers’ Perception of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

Corporate Social Responsibility and Investor Relations Management: Evidence from China

Earnings Pressure and Corporate Social Responsibility Impression Management

The Impact of Media on Corporate Social Responsibility

Does CSR Activity Amount to Socially Responsible Management?

Reading of Corporate Social Responsibility: Is It Beneficial for Business Organizations?